Watford model not one football should follow (From Lancashire Telegraph)
When news happens, text LT and your photos and videos to 80360. Or contact us by email or phone.
Watford model not one football should follow
9:47am Thursday 13th December 2012 in News
By Suzanne Geldard, Burnley FC reporter
WHEN Sean Dyche takes up his position in the tech-nical area on Saturday there will be something surreally familiar.
To mark his new club’s self-styled ‘Dychember’ movement, a fixture against his former employers and a ticket promotion to boost the attendance for the last home game before Christmas, up to 10,000 ‘lookalikes’ will be staring back at him.
He has seen the funny side of the mass produced masks of his goatee beards.
His old club, however, will look distinctly different, and in the grand scheme of football, it is no laughing matter.
Dyche’s dismissal from Vicarage Road in the summer was met with widespread disappointment, given what he had achieved in the first season of his first managerial job.
Sadly, it was not met with complete shock.
When the Pozzo family completed their takeover there seemed an almost inevitability about his exit, despite guiding them, on a restricted budget, to an 11th placed finish – a club best for four years – simply because he was not Gianfranco Zola.
There has been an almost complete overhaul of the then largely British playing staff by the Italian owners too.
Watford have 32 players on their books, including 14 on loan.
One is from Chelsea, 10 are from Serie A side Udinese, who also happen to be Pozzo-owned.
This is in stark contrast to the Hornets last season celebrating the 50th youngster to progress from youth team protege to professional since 1998.
In the current climate it’s impossible to see the next half century being achieved in double the time, let alone 14 years. What happens when these loan deals expire, where do Watford go then?
Clarets fans might question why they should care, why this concerns them. In some senses it shouldn’t.
It’s not their problem.
But in a wider sense, it is, because the situation is concerning for football.
There are restrictions on how many loan players you can field from domestic clubs, but not those from overseas, so there is nothing ‘legally’ wrong in Watford’s policy. Ethically and morally, however – well, that’s a different matter.
For all the focus on EPPP (Elite Player Performance Plan) and the theory that it will help produce better players for England, what use is it if their route to the senior squad is blocked by imports, albeit temporary ones.
When those players return to their parent clubs, others can be sent out.
There is nothing, at present, to stop other clubs following suit, which would leave the Football League becoming a finishing school for foreign teams.
There is no future in that.
Comments are closed on this article.

Comments (83)
10:11am Thu 13 Dec 12
RookeryHorn says...
Let me make it simple, our former owner is currently being charged by the FA because of illegal loan sharking against the security of transfer fees involved in the Danny Graham move. He was driving the club in one direction and it was to follow L*ton. So it's either that, or where we are now.
Anyway, you bang on about our '50' and the homegrown player rules, etc, we still field more academy produced youngsters than our opponents seem to manage, despite the influx of talent from the Pozzo network, also, as you've sort of half mentioned, the fact that they're on loan is purely an administrative formality, four of the players are joining permanently in January, but of course if you'd actually looked into the situation, you'd have found that out.
Also, things weren't always so rosey with Dyche as people like to make out, him being forced out was probably a blessing in disguise as his football wasn't pretty, he had a beyond awful start and was saved by the loan signings of Kightly, Kacaniklic, Kuszsack and Nosworthy. Whilst now we're playing nicer 'carpet' football if you will, got players that excite and look to be actually going places.
Don't let me stop you joining a blind bandwagon though.
10:11am Thu 13 Dec 12
MKgloryHorn says...
I can answer that.......WFC have the option to buy ALL of the loan players, so when they expire we either buy them or we dont, pretty simple really.
10:17am Thu 13 Dec 12
gaz967 says...
We've had 6 youngsters in and around the 18 man squad all season, including Tommie Hoban who's one of our best players.
We've also agreed to buy the four best loan players in January
10:20am Thu 13 Dec 12
Zorg the Leveller says...
The loans from Udinese are loans in name, they're effectively free transfers potentially. "Unfair"? Only in the sense that any foreign investment is unfair, I don't see the difference.
As for the suggestion that young players won't get a chance... three of our best have been given five year contracts by the new regime and the kids are getting no less gametime this season than last... Dyche was cautious in this respect.
I've written more on this here
http://thetwounfortu
nates.com/a-bluffers
-guide-to-watford-cl
****-of-2013/
10:20am Thu 13 Dec 12
RookeryHorn says...
Again, don't let the facts get in the way of a good old "FOREIGNERS ARE TAKING OUR JOBS!" story.
10:26am Thu 13 Dec 12
yellowarmy23 says...
10:30am Thu 13 Dec 12
aefevans says...
“Ethically and morally, however – well, that’s a different matter” – you see Rio Ferdinand being hit by coins, racist gestures aimed at players from fans, yet the finger points to Watford when it comes to ethics and morals.
This is a poor, poor article from Ms. Geldard. Almost like a belated jump on to the Watford-bashing bandwagon. Better luck next time, Suze.
10:36am Thu 13 Dec 12
gaz967 says...
0
10:36am Thu 13 Dec 12
Pieboy says...
I believe if the Pozzo's didn't take over, Watford would be in administration. Saving a club that has produced many good players isn't wrong in my book. Loaning players from Udinese is effectively cutting Watfords wage budget - which again, I see nothing wrong with financial control.
There's a lot of other clubs who are a disgrace before you pick on Watford.
Suzanne - You've truly embarrassed Lancashire with this ill-though out article. Please engage your brain before your next piece.
10:38am Thu 13 Dec 12
prop101 says...
10:48am Thu 13 Dec 12
@rookerymike says...
Firstly, I'm glad Burnley supporters have taken Sean Dyche to their hearts. Having met him on a number of occasions I can confirm he is a fine, upstanding chap, with a sense of humour to match his passion for football. He's a top man.
Whilst Sean Dyche's sacking at Watford was undoubtedly harsh, to say it was for "not being Gianfranco Zola" is hopelessly simplistic. The Pozzo family have a vision of what they want to achieve and how they want to make it a reality. Watford are playing the best football seen at the club in generations, and Zola has guided the team to 6th. Difficult to say that the switch hasn't been a success so far, isn't it? It's equally hard to be confident that Sean Dyche would have achieved the same results...
I'm not even going to dignify the "largely British playing staff" comment with a response, other than to wish you luck with your presumably ongoing mission to work at either the Daily Mail or Express.
You ask where Watford will be when the loan players go back? Well, you've already identified the fact that these aren't traditional loans, so firstly , how do you know they WILL go back? And what if, god forbid, the plan works and within a few years Watford are in the Premier League? Why WOULD they go back? Watford could find themselves in a situation where they have a settled squad of high quality players, that, shock horror, haven't cost an arm and a leg.
In terms of Watford and youth development, the link up with Harefield continues to be a success, and the Pozzo family have rewarded several graduates with five year contracts. If that's not showing commitment to our young players, I'm not really sure what is. Also, one of the front runners for player of the season this year is Tommie Hoban. On loan from...oh, hang on wait. He's a teenage Academy graduate.
I can understand opposition to Watford's current model, many Hornets fans have their own misgivings. What I can't understand is a lack of willing to investigate it fully and pass a considered judgement. I'd suggest it isn't Watford and the Pozzos that are bad for football. It's poor, ill thought out and barely researched stories like this that are the real cause for concern.
I'm sure we'll be back when you're ready for a serious debate.
10:53am Thu 13 Dec 12
Richard Johnson's Right Foot says...
s.com
10:53am Thu 13 Dec 12
swearengen says...
10:54am Thu 13 Dec 12
RookeryHorn says...
10:57am Thu 13 Dec 12
Pompey Claret says...
I hope your not thinking that this story is the thoughts of any true Clarets supporters or real football fans . Nor That of Sean Dyche?
What counts most is that Watford have a good manager and a team that are playing well at present and owners investing In the Club.
Good luck for the rest of the season but not for Saturday .
I think she can't find anything better to write about.
UTC
11:12am Thu 13 Dec 12
TommmB says...
6 months in and we are still forced to read the same lazy, ill-informed, poorly researched garbage each week
Number of academy products featured in Burnley's most recent match day squad: 0
Number of academy products featured in Watford's most recent match day squad: 3
Give it a rest will you
11:21am Thu 13 Dec 12
Pieboy says...
11:23am Thu 13 Dec 12
lockerbiehornet says...
It's a shame the News of the World isn't around anymore, I think they'd have identified a budding journalist here!
11:27am Thu 13 Dec 12
lockerbiehornet says...
11:27am Thu 13 Dec 12
lockerbiehornet says...
11:28am Thu 13 Dec 12
claretmaduk says...
11:32am Thu 13 Dec 12
ClaretSince94 says...
Well for starters Chris McCann is 25 and for seconds we also had Jay Rodriguez in that lineup which means we had two academy products...pot, kettle, black etc.
11:33am Thu 13 Dec 12
pete500 says...
11:40am Thu 13 Dec 12
Watford1994 says...
11:41am Thu 13 Dec 12
bobinspain says...
well-reasoned, educated, literate and articulate postings in this rag.
It's more than I've come to expect of both professionals and distinctly un-gifted amateurs flitting in and out of these putative 'soccer pages.'
You're welcome anytime. It makes a refreshing change.
11:42am Thu 13 Dec 12
@rookerymike says...
Also, I think you'll find that the comparison was made not to have a pop at Burnley, but to highlight the fact that the article doesn't seem to be massively well thought out.
Fair play to you for missing the point so well though, you've done almost as good a job as the articles author in that respect.
Cheers.
11:45am Thu 13 Dec 12
NickWFC says...
11:54am Thu 13 Dec 12
Pieboy says...
Besides, surely you've just proven our point? We currently 2-4 in our match day squad (Being Doyley, Hoban, Smith and Murray) yet, we're everything that's wrong with football? With that out look, what does that make Burnley?
All the best for the season after Saturday.
11:55am Thu 13 Dec 12
Blackburn fans love horses says...
You have to admit though guys that the model of loaning players between the owner's respective clubs is stretching the rules somewhat?
I appreciate you are 'doing nothing wrong' as far as the rules are concerned, but are you not concerned that you have lost the flow of academy players into your first team that you have previously had?
12:05pm Thu 13 Dec 12
gaz967 says...
Over the past 10 or so years, we've had to promote so many due to financial restrictions.
The club have given 5 year deals to Hoban, Murray and Smith - all of which have featured in our first XI this season. Zola has been more willing to give playing time to our younger players than Dyche did
12:09pm Thu 13 Dec 12
Return of the Magnificent se7en says...
Typical keep on hanging on this its coz as british rubbish, thats why you are 17th and when flash in the pan austin leaves in Jan you can have a british themed relegation party.
Dick van dyke can provide the entertainment doin the ol bamboo and you can have a right knees up, maybe chas n dave will appear in your wood burning stove supply of a ground.
Chim Chiminee.
12:16pm Thu 13 Dec 12
Blackburn fans love horses says...
How's your new manager doing?
How are your fantastic owners?
Congratulations on it being exactly two years to the day since you sacked Big Fat Sam Allardyce.
Now run along back to your hovel
12:23pm Thu 13 Dec 12
Pieboy says...
12:39pm Thu 13 Dec 12
akureyri says...
All you Hornets have forgotten the goalkeepers. Jack Bonham and Jonathan Bond are academy boys and have made the match squad this season, also Jonathan Bond has started one game this season - which probably would have been more if Scott Loach, who was at Watford from such a young age he appeared to come from the academy, had stayed.
1:00pm Thu 13 Dec 12
watford_anne says...
I read with some dismay the above article, bemoaning as it does, Watford Football Team's use of Italian football players. I would point out to you that Italy is a good, Christian country and Watford are to be congratulated on their willingness to promote young Christian boys ahead of less welcome outsiders.
My main reason for visiting this afternoon however, is to inform you that for the first time this season, we - The Watford Christian Fellowship (part of the Family First Network) are hosting one of our ever popular events at your Turfed Moor ground on Saturday.
We will have football-themed thimbles, coasters and other memorabilia for sale, the proceeds of which go to the vital fight against stem-cell research. I hope you will have an opportunity to come and visit us at the entrance to the cricket club from 1.30pm.
Best wishes,
Anne Ferguson (Mrs)
1:03pm Thu 13 Dec 12
TommmB says...
Pretty sure Jay Rodriguez plays for Southampton now...
As far McCann, yes he is a youth product but hardly a 'hot young prospect'. We are still bringing through teenagers and playing them week in week out at Championship level
1:10pm Thu 13 Dec 12
Blackburn fans love horses says...
Who do you think will get first dibs on a starting place - a random Italian loan player being paid a decent amount every week or Johnny Homegrown on a couple of hundred pounds?
Zola would play the player HE signed every time.
1:15pm Thu 13 Dec 12
RookeryHorn says...
1) Zola didn't sign those loan players, Nani did.
2) We have ONE Italian player, your stereotype is pants.
3) Our very own Tommie Hoban has been played ahead of 3 other centre backs brought in on loan on occasion.
1:19pm Thu 13 Dec 12
JohnnyBarnes says...
Along with taking the time to do a bit of research in advance of publishing this sort of tripe, it might also be a good idea to direct your resentment more appropriately.
1:46pm Thu 13 Dec 12
TommmB says...
They are playing every single week
18 year old Tommie Hoban has 14 starts at centre back this season, whilst Fanchone from Udinese sits on the bench
19 year old Sean Murray has 12 appearances whilst Battochio from Udinese sits on the bench
19 year old Connor Smith has 7 appearances already in his debut season
This is a meritocracy, if they are good enough they will play every single week
1:59pm Thu 13 Dec 12
George White Bread says...
2:12pm Thu 13 Dec 12
Blackburn fans love horses says...
Seeing as you are playing pedantic games you actually have TWO Italian players (Battocchio and Forestieri)
2:15pm Thu 13 Dec 12
nathwfc says...
2:23pm Thu 13 Dec 12
Pieboy says...
Marco Cassetti is Italian.
2:24pm Thu 13 Dec 12
Blackburn fans love horses says...
We did the same thing with Kieran Tripper and Ben Mee - loaned them from Man City for a season and then bought them permanently in January
2:26pm Thu 13 Dec 12
Blackburn fans love horses says...
:-)
2:33pm Thu 13 Dec 12
watford_anne says...
Might I suggest you keep your vile, leftist, secularist, anti-British, anti-Christian thoughts to yourself?
Thank you,
Anne Ferguson (Mrs)
2:40pm Thu 13 Dec 12
u0rns. says...
Put some research into the subject before you put it to print.
@ Blackburn fans love horses - Cristian Battocchio is Argentinian not Italian (you could do with doing some research as well)!
2:40pm Thu 13 Dec 12
ClaretSince94 says...
But if you want me to focus more on the actual point you and your fellow Watford supporters are making then fine - if the Pozzo's are really keyed in to allowing Watford to develop their own homegrown players what about the downscaling of your academy from what was already approved as a category 1 down to category 3? This makes the "5 year deals" sound more like short term fan appeasement to distract from this - seems to be working?
On our own youth front we have been making more investments on this front recently but obviously this takes time show results. We're starting to see the results now - last year our youth team made the FA Youth Cup semi-final and just last week knocked Manchester United out of the same competition at Old Trafford. One of our under 18's is already a full international and represented his country at the Olympics and is being tracked by Liverpool and Newcastle. Howieson and Hewitt have both been in match days squads and were rewarded with pro deals ahead of schedule in the past year. I believe once Dyche settles into the role and has time to assess the youth prospects at the club we'll start to see more making the step up.
2:43pm Thu 13 Dec 12
Blackburn fans love horses says...
And you are sexist (Mrs) Ferguson.
Oh, and by your last comment I will not be buying one of your tacky thimbles now either.
Goodbye
2:55pm Thu 13 Dec 12
RookeryHorn says...
We already have the coaching setup, the amount of hours, the facilities that better all Cat 2 and a lot of Cat 1 academies, we just choose not to play in that pointless 'Development League' and choose not to invest the required amount.
When we progress (and/or go up), we'll be re-visiting that choice.
Cat 1 isn't a necessity to attract and produce youngsters, we've still managed to pull off signing one of the more sought after 14 year olds in the world, as an example.
2:56pm Thu 13 Dec 12
RookeryHorn says...
3:08pm Thu 13 Dec 12
watford_anne says...
3:10pm Thu 13 Dec 12
claretmaduk says...
If I was a young player now aged 12 I would think twice about joining a club who have loaned so many foreign players so quickly, whether or u sign then permanently or not. Personally I hope they keep your youth developing ethos and you continue to reap the benefits
3:16pm Thu 13 Dec 12
Blackburn fans love horses says...
At first I though you were just being a little sarcastic, but unfortunately it appears you are now showing your true colours.
Are you sure your name isn't Griffiths (Mrs)? You embarrassment for a person.
3:22pm Thu 13 Dec 12
fanny_tickler. says...
3:35pm Thu 13 Dec 12
midas says...
3:37pm Thu 13 Dec 12
ClaretSince94 says...
If your club was being developed by the Pozzo's surely they would have made the investment? By not doing so, by dropping down from what you had the facilities for for financial reasons seems to suggest they would prefer you to develop players from their parent club?
3:39pm Thu 13 Dec 12
watford_anne says...
Racism is a crime and cime is for non-Christians
I believe it's rife in your part of the world, quelle surprise
Anne Ferguson (Mrs)
3:44pm Thu 13 Dec 12
u0rns. says...
ing set-up has no bearing on the players produced, if they're good enough they will get first team football.
One of the main reasons the club was purchased was the youth set-up. It complements the Pozzo scouting network perfectly and will no doubt make them and the club a lot of money.
re. signings; The club have already stated that 6 of the "loan" players have agreed to sign in January. The only reason they didn't sign previously was because of an embargo imposed by the football league. (worth reading into, we were allegedly nearly bankrupt by our former Chairman).
There's a real stink of jealousy from the small clubs in the league but accusations of foul play are completely unfounded and unfair.
(1 )http://www.just-foo
tball.com/2011/11/wa
tford-fc-youth-acade
my-hertfordshires-ve
ry-own-la-masia/
(2) http://www.theharefi
eldacademy.org/page/
?title=Watford+FC+De
velopment+Squad&pid=
320
(3) http://www.bbc.co.uk
/blogs/paulfletcher/
2010/12/watford_offe
r_a_glimpse_of_the.h
tml
3:45pm Thu 13 Dec 12
Blackburn fans love horses says...
I find it ironic that a Watford fan feels the need to comment on Burnley's racial issues - when in factWatford is a subdivision of the Greater London Area, all of which means you are part of a city that now has a 55% ethnic MAJORITY.
3:47pm Thu 13 Dec 12
Blackburn fans love horses says...
Seems like you have got the Blackburn syndrome sunshine - have a look at our respective histories and then come back and see who is the 'small club'
3:52pm Thu 13 Dec 12
u0rns. says...
Why would we pay £ 2 million to sign up to a youth league and to guarantee Prem clubs won't poach our players? The academy is already widely acclaimed as the best in the country and if a Prem club tries to sign a player we don't want to sell the owners can just transfer his ownership to a club not covered by EPPP, like Udinesse or Granada. Players protected, academy still churning out quality players, money still in the bank.
EPPP isn't a way of improving the nations youth system, its a way to stop smaller clubs from charging Premier League clubs top price for decent youth products.
3:55pm Thu 13 Dec 12
fanny_tickler. says...
4:01pm Thu 13 Dec 12
Bringe says...
WFC are operating under Fifa rules, rules that were written for the gain of the European giants with feeder clubs and that we have turned the tables on them if anything should be applauded. Perhaps now authorities will see fit to banish their unfair regulations, perhaps not but the Pozzo's are honorable folk who will always act within set parameters (unlike their predecessor).
Assuming the plan works and we are promoted it will do English football no harm, our academy continues to thrive and that their will be Brits having learnt comprehensive continental systems and techniques could have a positive impact internationally, few would deny that we and the home nations have been lagging behind for decades.
4:03pm Thu 13 Dec 12
u0rns. says...
Back to the point - 1-4 on Saturday and then you can moan about how unfair it is again ;-)
4:28pm Thu 13 Dec 12
Blackburn fans love horses says...
I expect an easy three points for the Clarets to be honest, we are in decent nick at home and Austin is due a goal or two.
4:28pm Thu 13 Dec 12
Lloydinio says...
4:40pm Thu 13 Dec 12
Bringe says...
4:51pm Thu 13 Dec 12
claretmaduk says...
5:34pm Thu 13 Dec 12
ClaretSince94 says...
5:36pm Thu 13 Dec 12
u0rns. says...
Not sure who's gonna score the goals though, Deeney has 9, Vydra 8, Abdi has 5, Yeates 3, Forestieri 3, Anya 2, Hoban 2 and 5 others on 1.
Its a sure bet that we'll score a few though.
7:19pm Thu 13 Dec 12
darrenbazeley says...
7:37pm Thu 13 Dec 12
darrenbazeley says...
8:02pm Thu 13 Dec 12
claretmaduk says...
8:07pm Thu 13 Dec 12
Smilingburkinshaw says...
8:15pm Thu 13 Dec 12
claretmaduk says...
8:23pm Thu 13 Dec 12
darrenbazeley says...
8:30pm Thu 13 Dec 12
Smilingburkinshaw says...
9:49pm Thu 13 Dec 12
Glasgow Hornet says...
To the football - I still have a bad taste about how Dyche was sacked and I'm glad he's back in football. The current Watford set-up does at first sight seem odd, but many of the loans were last-minute (before deadline day).
I do think this system has some benefits though (for Watford and Udinese) and perhaps "small" clubs might explore this further. It may yet be a way of levelling the playing field against the bully-boy money-men who own the so called BIG clubs. What is more ethical, sharing between like minded clubs or throwing money you don't have at buying "big name" players?
8:42am Fri 14 Dec 12
jackmetickler says...
Ah well, you get what you vote for eh!
8:50am Fri 14 Dec 12
jasonwatford says...
.Charlie Austin i believe will want to try his luck in premership and might go to Reading or Villa but too good to stay at Burnley. We will only get better as season goes on and if we dont get lucky this year next year we will i believe. Many of you wont get to see Forreisteri tomorrow as has slight injury but one day you will see him in Prem with us or someone else. Good luck to Burnley and Sean have a good season...Blackburn you have have a bunch of jokers in charge...Sevi singh or whoever the guy is knows nothing about football at all and you fans will now reap the rewards of treating Keen so badly. He may not been the best but better than what you got now or will attract in future , Leeds and Forest and Bradford did what you your doing and it takes time to get back.
12:50pm Fri 14 Dec 12
hornet90 says...