Burnley dementia sufferer, 78, scared to go out after being mugged by woman

VICTIM Billy Robinson VICTIM Billy Robinson

A FRAIL 78-year-old man suffering from dementia was mugged in the street by a woman.

Former Burnley publican William ‘Billy’ Robinson, 78, was targeted deliberately by heroin addict Carmen Dean because he was vulnerable, a court heard.

Mr Robinson’s family said the actions of Dean had ‘ripped his life apart’ and ruined his confidence, to the point that he was now scared to be out on his own.

The former soldier in the East Lancashire Regiment, who did his national service in Egypt, used to go the Victoria pub, Colne Road, every afternoon but had not but had not been back on his own since the attack.

Widower Mr Robinson, a father and grandfather of 10, was outside the post office in Hebrew Road, Burnley, near his home at around 4.15pm when he was targeted by Dean.

She has been jailed for one year, a sentence his family said did not reflect the seriousness of the crime.

Denise Dixon, Mr Robinson’s 51-year-old daughter, who works in the catering department at Burnley General Hospital, said: “It is deplorable that my dad was targeted in this way, just because he was vulnerable. It is heartbreaking.

“It has ruined his confidence. He used to go to the pub every afternoon for a couple of hours, but now he can’t go in. He has been to the front door a few times but he won’t go in on his own.

“We just want him to go back to that, that is normal for him, that is his life and it has been taken from him.”

Mr Robinson, who has suffered from dementia for two years, ran pubs and clubs in Burnley for over 25 years, before ending his working career as a driver for Burnley-based bakery firm Turkington’s.

He and his wife, Kathleen, who died in 2000, ran the Daneshouse Club, before spending 23 years in charge of the Concert Artistes Club in the town centre, six months at a private members club in Whalley and time in charge of the Pleasant Home and Pride Working Men’s Club in Burnham Gate.

Mrs Dixon, who visits her dad every morning and evening and cares for him along with brother Mark, 47, and husband David, 52, said: “He is so well known in the Burnley area, and in Duke Bar. A lot of people look out for him and are appalled at what has happened.

“I have spoken to the dementia team and they said it could take six months before he gets over the attack and what has happened, but we just want him to be back to normal, we want him to be enjoying going to the pub and seeing friends again.”

At Burnley Crown Court Michael Wallbank, prosecuting, said witnesses saw Dean, 40, of Percy Street, Nelson, holding the pensioner by the shirt, pulling him and dragging him around on July 23.

The court heard that Dean, who had 42 previous convictions, was then seen walking away with Mr Robinson’s wallet. When challenged by witnesses she claimed she knew him, calling Mr Robinson ‘George’.

She tried to run off but was caught by one of the witnesses and detained until police arrived, while an ambulance was called for Mr Robinson, who was now complaining of chest pains.

He was taken to hospital and when he was allowed home he required 24-hour care for four weeks.

Richard Taylor, representing Dean, said: “Drink and drugs have really spoiled this lady's life for the last 20 years.

“The defendant presents today as somewhat pathetic in herself. She is very tearful, she is very upset about what has happened and she wishes to apologise not only to the victim, but to the court.”

Sentencing, Recorder Andrew Long said: “I am satisfied that you deliberately targeted the victim because he was very vulnerable and was incapable of defending himself from you.

“It is most fortunate that two members of the public were able to prevent this getting any worse than it did.”

Mrs Dixon said the sentence was not long enough for the family: “We haven't got any joy from this sentence. I am absolutely disgusted. She has torn his life apart yet will be walking away while we are still trying to get back to where we were. Where is the justice in that?”

Comments (17)

12:08pm Wed 12 Sep 12

Stuart Farquar says...

42 previous convictions and she gets sent down for 1 year for this ?!? Disgusting ! If it had been an MP that had been attacked she wouldn't see the streets again and that is a fact! What a revolting scrotey lowlife !! Next time she might kill someone and then get a year and a half. Poor bloke what a revolting chit hole of a country !
42 previous convictions and she gets sent down for 1 year for this ?!? Disgusting ! If it had been an MP that had been attacked she wouldn't see the streets again and that is a fact! What a revolting scrotey lowlife !! Next time she might kill someone and then get a year and a half. Poor bloke what a revolting chit hole of a country ! Stuart Farquar

12:17pm Wed 12 Sep 12

Elsie C says...

Carmen Dean - absolute scum, should be shot at birth. There should be no place in soceity for scum like this.
Carmen Dean - absolute scum, should be shot at birth. There should be no place in soceity for scum like this. Elsie C

1:04pm Wed 12 Sep 12

BritainfortheBritish says...

Elsie C wrote:
Carmen Dean - absolute scum, should be shot at birth. There should be no place in soceity for scum like this.
Totally agree ! And just what has happened to decent sentencing these days .No one seems to get the sentence they deserve.
[quote][p][bold]Elsie C[/bold] wrote: Carmen Dean - absolute scum, should be shot at birth. There should be no place in soceity for scum like this.[/p][/quote]Totally agree ! And just what has happened to decent sentencing these days .No one seems to get the sentence they deserve. BritainfortheBritish

5:15pm Wed 12 Sep 12

shirl72 says...

poor bloke served the country worked all his life and she gets 12month and her solictor called her a lady wat a joke she is nothing but lowlife scum and hope she gets her karmer absoulte shocking she as reunied the rest of his life hope her inmates know excatly wat she is in for cant belive wat i ave just read and 42 other convictions so mad i hope his family appeal and she gets what she really deserves
poor bloke served the country worked all his life and she gets 12month and her solictor called her a lady wat a joke she is nothing but lowlife scum and hope she gets her karmer absoulte shocking she as reunied the rest of his life hope her inmates know excatly wat she is in for cant belive wat i ave just read and 42 other convictions so mad i hope his family appeal and she gets what she really deserves shirl72

5:26pm Wed 12 Sep 12

l m h jones says...

have to agree with sentiments of other commentators and hope that Mr Robinson does regain his confidence and health but what i find equally revolting is that Richard Taylor, representing Dean, said: “Drink and drugs have really spoiled this lady's life for the last 20 years" well tough lady don't drink and don't do drugs and then maybe you wouldn't attack elderly men in the street. .a year with 42 previous convictions?
have to agree with sentiments of other commentators and hope that Mr Robinson does regain his confidence and health but what i find equally revolting is that Richard Taylor, representing Dean, said: “Drink and drugs have really spoiled this lady's life for the last 20 years" well tough lady don't drink and don't do drugs and then maybe you wouldn't attack elderly men in the street. .a year with 42 previous convictions? l m h jones

5:26pm Wed 12 Sep 12

l m h jones says...

have to agree with sentiments of other commentators and hope that Mr Robinson does regain his confidence and health but what i find equally revolting is that Richard Taylor, representing Dean, said: “Drink and drugs have really spoiled this lady's life for the last 20 years" well tough lady don't drink and don't do drugs and then maybe you wouldn't attack elderly men in the street. .a year with 42 previous convictions?
have to agree with sentiments of other commentators and hope that Mr Robinson does regain his confidence and health but what i find equally revolting is that Richard Taylor, representing Dean, said: “Drink and drugs have really spoiled this lady's life for the last 20 years" well tough lady don't drink and don't do drugs and then maybe you wouldn't attack elderly men in the street. .a year with 42 previous convictions? l m h jones

5:27pm Wed 12 Sep 12

hunter3062 says...

Recorder Andrew Long hang your head in shame.
Recorder Andrew Long hang your head in shame. hunter3062

6:03pm Wed 12 Sep 12

shirl72 says...

mr robinson wasnt the one who got the lowlife on drink and drugs but now he will suffer becose of deans habbit and she will be out in about six month to ruin someone elses life without a doubt with 42 other convictions behind loose the key to her cell
mr robinson wasnt the one who got the lowlife on drink and drugs but now he will suffer becose of deans habbit and she will be out in about six month to ruin someone elses life without a doubt with 42 other convictions behind loose the key to her cell shirl72

6:31pm Wed 12 Sep 12

golazzo says...

I do hope everyone makes a mental note of what she looks like for when she's released.

Not that I condone violence
I do hope everyone makes a mental note of what she looks like for when she's released. Not that I condone violence golazzo

7:18pm Wed 12 Sep 12

Heretical says...

It's time that victim impact statements were taken into account when sentencing is done.
Perhaps then justice would be better served.
It's time that victim impact statements were taken into account when sentencing is done. Perhaps then justice would be better served. Heretical

5:37am Thu 13 Sep 12

sharonpickering@rocketmail.com says...

What has happened to the justice system in this country? it's gone to the dogs. I hope your dad and grand-dad is soon back in the pub with his friends.
What has happened to the justice system in this country? it's gone to the dogs. I hope your dad and grand-dad is soon back in the pub with his friends. sharonpickering@rocketmail.com

8:36am Thu 13 Sep 12

BritainfortheBritish says...

I think the fact our jails are full and many of the prisoners being immigrants offenders are getting let off with more and more serious crimes because there is either no room or it costs to much .
Send foreign prisoners to their own country to serve their sentence and this will free up cells for scum like this to serve longer and save money for the country.
I think the fact our jails are full and many of the prisoners being immigrants offenders are getting let off with more and more serious crimes because there is either no room or it costs to much . Send foreign prisoners to their own country to serve their sentence and this will free up cells for scum like this to serve longer and save money for the country. BritainfortheBritish

3:19pm Fri 14 Sep 12

HecticBigBoy says...

Stuart Farquar wrote:
42 previous convictions and she gets sent down for 1 year for this ?!? Disgusting ! If it had been an MP that had been attacked she wouldn't see the streets again and that is a fact! What a revolting scrotey lowlife !! Next time she might kill someone and then get a year and a half. Poor bloke what a revolting chit hole of a country !
Exactly my thoughts, 42 previous, i'm bloody sure 1 year will cure her of that 'problem', i feel for the old fella, he will not be over it in 12 months. Pathetic justice system.
[quote][p][bold]Stuart Farquar[/bold] wrote: 42 previous convictions and she gets sent down for 1 year for this ?!? Disgusting ! If it had been an MP that had been attacked she wouldn't see the streets again and that is a fact! What a revolting scrotey lowlife !! Next time she might kill someone and then get a year and a half. Poor bloke what a revolting chit hole of a country ![/p][/quote]Exactly my thoughts, 42 previous, i'm bloody sure 1 year will cure her of that 'problem', i feel for the old fella, he will not be over it in 12 months. Pathetic justice system. HecticBigBoy

3:21pm Fri 14 Sep 12

HecticBigBoy says...

l m h jones wrote:
have to agree with sentiments of other commentators and hope that Mr Robinson does regain his confidence and health but what i find equally revolting is that Richard Taylor, representing Dean, said: “Drink and drugs have really spoiled this lady's life for the last 20 years" well tough lady don't drink and don't do drugs and then maybe you wouldn't attack elderly men in the street. .a year with 42 previous convictions?
Shame she hasn't drunk herself to death or taken an 'accidental' overdose, save us all money and get rid of this dangerous nasty piece of sh** off the streets.
[quote][p][bold]l m h jones[/bold] wrote: have to agree with sentiments of other commentators and hope that Mr Robinson does regain his confidence and health but what i find equally revolting is that Richard Taylor, representing Dean, said: “Drink and drugs have really spoiled this lady's life for the last 20 years" well tough lady don't drink and don't do drugs and then maybe you wouldn't attack elderly men in the street. .a year with 42 previous convictions?[/p][/quote]Shame she hasn't drunk herself to death or taken an 'accidental' overdose, save us all money and get rid of this dangerous nasty piece of sh** off the streets. HecticBigBoy

3:23pm Fri 14 Sep 12

HecticBigBoy says...

golazzo wrote:
I do hope everyone makes a mental note of what she looks like for when she's released. Not that I condone violence
Ooooh I'm sure 12 months will cure her alcoholism and drug habit!!!!! Won't it??? The legal system thinks so.
[quote][p][bold]golazzo[/bold] wrote: I do hope everyone makes a mental note of what she looks like for when she's released. Not that I condone violence[/p][/quote]Ooooh I'm sure 12 months will cure her alcoholism and drug habit!!!!! Won't it??? The legal system thinks so. HecticBigBoy

8:52pm Mon 17 Sep 12

HairyBowls says...

Rope!
Rope! HairyBowls

11:15am Thu 20 Sep 12

HecticBigBoy says...

HairyBowls wrote:
Rope!
100% agree
[quote][p][bold]HairyBowls[/bold] wrote: Rope![/p][/quote]100% agree HecticBigBoy

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree