Martin Lewis hits out at Ofgem over Market Stabilisation Charge

Martin Lewis has criticised Ofgem for pressing ahead with the Market Stabilisation Charge, warning it could make cheaper energy deals less competitive when wholesale prices fall. <i>(Image: PA)</i>
Martin Lewis has criticised Ofgem for pressing ahead with the Market Stabilisation Charge, warning it could make cheaper energy deals less competitive when wholesale prices fall. (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Martin Lewis has hit out at Ofgem over its decision to press ahead with a controversial energy switching charge, warning households could miss out on the full benefit if wholesale prices fall.

The Money Saving Expert criticised the regulator in a new post on X, accusing it of going ahead with a plan that could make cheaper energy deals more expensive for people looking to switch supplier.

Martin wrote: "What c**p from @ofgem. It's just announced this consultation is over it is doing this exactly as planned. So now even if wholesale rates drop, consumers will be denied the full benefit when they switch @Miatsf please look into this."

His comments concern the Market Stabilisation Charge (MSC), a mechanism that would require an energy supplier gaining a customer to make a payment to the supplier losing them, if wholesale prices fall sharply.

The charge is intended to protect suppliers that have already bought energy in advance for customers on standard variable tariffs, but Martin has repeatedly warned that it could weaken competition and limit the savings available to households switching to cheaper deals.

Ofgem ran its consultation on activating the charge last month. The regulator said the measure would help protect consumers' interests by supporting market stability and suppliers' ability to manage wholesale energy purchases.

Martin had warned about the proposal when the consultation first launched, saying it could act as a penalty for switching.

In his earlier post, published on October 16, he said: "In a nutshell, it means if wholesale energy prices drop sharply, the cheap fixes and switcher's deals offered will be a lot more expensive, in order to protect energy firms' profits."

He argued that a supplier taking on a new customer would have to compensate that customer's previous provider if they switched, meaning some of the benefit of lower wholesale prices could be lost.

How the Market Stabilisation Charge works

Under the proposed mechanism, the charge would be triggered if wholesale prices fell by more than 10% below the level built into the energy price cap.

If that happened, a supplier gaining a customer would have to pay the previous supplier 85% of the fall in wholesale prices beyond that 10% threshold.

Martin used a simplified example to explain how this could affect customers.

He imagined wholesale energy costs built into the price cap standing at £1,000. If prices fell to £900, the charge would not apply.

But if they dropped to £800, the first £100 reduction would be unaffected, while 85% of the next £100 – equivalent to £85 – would be paid to the customer's former supplier.

Martin said the new supplier would almost certainly pass that cost on through the tariff it offered, meaning the deal could be up to £85 more expensive than it would otherwise have been.

He stressed that this was a simplified illustration, rather than a precise prediction of what households would pay.

In his original post, he said: "In other words, the new supplier can't pass a chunk of the saving from lower wholesale rates on to you, because it has to hand much of it to your old supplier."

Why Ofgem wants to introduce the charge

Ofgem's argument is that energy suppliers buy electricity and gas in advance to cover the needs of customers on price-capped tariffs.

If wholesale prices then fall sharply, customers may leave those tariffs in large numbers to secure cheaper fixed deals elsewhere. Their former suppliers could be left with energy bought at higher prices than the market rate.

The regulator says the Market Stabilisation Charge would help reduce those losses and support market stability.

However, Martin questioned whether the measure was necessary, arguing that the supplier market was now more stable than during the energy crisis earlier in the decade.


Recommended reading:


He also said he was concerned that protecting suppliers from potential losses could come at the expense of competition and cheaper deals for consumers.

In his October post, he wrote: "I don't like it. This is a 'Market Stabilisation Charge' but the supplier market is pretty stable, and I doubt we are at the domino risk of suppliers going bust in the way they did in the early twenties."

He added: "After all we don't take their profits off them when they make them 'through no fault'."

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos