A Lancashire GP who was previously hailed as a hero after helping save the lives of two professional footballers has been struck off for having a sexual relationship with a vulnerable patient.
Dr Jonathan Tobin, who worked at Kirkham Health Centre, has been erased from the medical register after a tribunal found his misconduct was at the “highest end” of the scale of seriousness.
The experienced GP admitted having a sexual relationship with the patient while she remained registered at his practice, including having sexual contact with her at the surgery while he was working.
He also admitted arranging appointments for which there was no clinical reason and making false entries in her medical records to cover up the relationship.
Dr Tobin, who qualified in 1995, had been a GP partner since 2014 and had known the woman for around six or seven years before their relationship began in July 2024.
Before the misconduct came to light, however, Dr Tobin had attracted national attention through his work in professional football.
Dr Jonathan Tobin has been erased from the medical register (Image: Kirkham Health Centre/Facebook)
He was involved in the efforts to save former Bolton Wanderers midfielder Fabrice Muamba after he suffered a cardiac arrest during an FA Cup tie at Tottenham in 2012.
Nine years later, while working as Wigan Athletic's club doctor, he was credited by striker Charlie Wyke with saving his life after he suffered a cardiac arrest during training.
Dr Tobin worked for the Latics between 2017 and 2023.
But the tribunal heard how his relationship with Patient A began after the pair kissed during a consultation in July 2024.
Dr Tobin subsequently admitted engaging in sexual activity with her at the practice while he was working, as well as arranging medically unnecessary appointments and making dishonest entries in her records to disguise the true purpose of their meetings.
The tribunal was told Dr Tobin had falsely recorded information about the patient, including marking her as having failed to attend appointments and recording information which gave a misleading impression of her health.
In his evidence, Dr Tobin accepted his own approach to patients had contributed to what happened.
He told the tribunal his “drive to be popular overrode my desire to be efficient and safe” and admitted “small transgressions made me popular”.
The tribunal said his informal and friendly style, including his use of humour, may have affected his interactions with the patient before he allowed himself to become excited by her presence.
It also heard that Dr Tobin had suffered three close bereavements and was experiencing serious difficulties in his marriage around the time of the misconduct.
Read more
-
Trial of man accused of stalking and coercive control delayed to next year
-
Hyndburn man admits violent offences but will stand trial over alleged rape
-
Shoplifters and fuel fraudsters among recent cases heard by magistrates'
He told the tribunal that through the relationship he had “found a feeling of peace, being with someone that wanted me”, although he did not seek to use his personal circumstances to excuse his behaviour.
His barrister said Dr Tobin had accepted complete responsibility and had come before the tribunal to “tell the truth and face the music”.
He had undertaken training on professional boundaries and medical ethics as well as psychotherapy, with his barrister arguing there was a “vanishing prospect” that his behaviour would be repeated.
The tribunal accepted that Dr Tobin had taken significant steps to address his behaviour, including completing a course covering medical ethics, appropriate boundaries and honesty in clinical practice.
However, it found his response had not fully addressed how he came to enter into the relationship and ruled there remained risks to patient safety, public confidence in doctors and professional standards.
It assessed the ongoing risk to patient safety as “moderate”, but said the risk to public confidence in the medical profession and professional standards remained “high”.
His fitness to practise was therefore found to be impaired by misconduct.
The tribunal ultimately ruled that erasing Dr Tobin from the medical register was the only appropriate sanction, despite acknowledging his previous work as a “fine doctor” and considering testimonials which described his behaviour as out of character.
Share