Breaking

Company guilty of corporate manslaughter after worker's death

5
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A company, its owner and yard manager have been found guilty after a man died on a site with “an alarming pattern of unsafe practices”.

John Graveson, 42, was tragically killed after being crushed by a Hyundai HW140 excavator on March 3, 2023, while working at a skip hire yard in Outram Road, Dukinfield.

More than three years on the company AMP NW Ltd has been found guilty of corporate manslaughter after a trial at Manchester Crown Court.

Owner Anthony Elston, 49, was convicted of a Section 2 Health and Safety at Work Act offence, while yard manager John Horan, 34, was convicted of a Section 7 offence under the same act.

After his death, Mr Graveson's partner Shelly spoke about the “incredible man” she and his other loved ones had lost.

She said: “As the legal process comes to an end, sadly our grief does not.

“John was an incredible man whose warmth and love left an indelible mark on everyone lucky enough to know him.

Tributes were paid to Mr Graveson by his partner Shelly (Image: GMP)

“He was a truly lovable, huggable soul who embraced life with a wide-open heart, finding his greatest purpose in the deep devotion he held for his daughter, his partner, his mum.

“Laughter, Love Island and music were the best medicine for a brilliant day.

“His presence was a source of comfort and light, making the void he leaves behind feel impossibly vast.

“John should never have gone to work and not turned home to his family, and this will be a devastating reality forever as his daughter reaches many milestones in his absence.

“Life is so much quieter without John in it.

John Graveson with his partner Shelly (Image: GMP)

“You are loved beyond any describing word with love from Manchester all the way up to Carlisle, to his mum and wider family.”

According to Companies House, AMP NW Ltd is based in Groby Road, Audenshaw, while court documents give its address as Ringley Chase, Whitefield.

Police say that on the morning of March 3, 2023, yard manager Horan, of The Crescent, Worsthorne, was operating a Hyundai HW140 excavator in the yard.

At the same time, Mr Graveson, who had worked at the site as a waste picker for about a year, was walking through the yard and moved alongside the excavator before continuing behind it.

John Graveson died at the age of 42 (Image: GMP)

As Mr Graveson passed behind the excavator, Horan placed the vehicle into reverse and began manoeuvring backwards.

Although the excavator's reversing alarm was sounding and its blue warning lights were illuminated, Horan remained facing forwards and failed to see Mr Graveson behind the vehicle.

The excavator struck Mr Graveson and crushed him, causing catastrophic injuries from which he sadly died at the scene.

At 10.48am, the police were notified by the NWAS of a serious workplace incident at AMP Skip Hire on Outram Road, Dukinfield.

Officers were called and started a joint investigation with the Health and Safety Executive.

It was established that the excavator was fitted with a 360-degree camera system designed to provide the operator with full visibility while reversing.

A company and two men have been convicted over the death of John Graveson (Image: GMP)

But at the time of the collision, the camera system was not activated.

Investigators also established that the vehicle's side mirrors had been folded in.

The driver, Horan, reversed the excavator without making proper observations behind the vehicle, leading to the fatal crash.

Police say further enquiries, including extensive CCTV analysis from the weeks and days leading up to the incident, revealed a culture of unsafe working practices within the yard.

Investigators found repeated examples of pedestrians working near moving heavy plant machinery.

They also found workers crossing behind reversing vehicles, personnel remaining in loading and tipping areas during vehicle movements, and individuals standing beneath suspended loads.

The footage showed that owner Elston, of Wicket Grove, Clifton, was present while these dangerous practices were taking place and these practices had become commonplace on site.

His failure to intervene or take effective action demonstrated a significant breakdown in the management of health and safety.

The investigation found safety controls, risk management measures and safe systems of work were inadequate and were not being consistently enforced prior to the death of Mr Graveson.

Horan was arrested following the incident on suspicion of gross negligence manslaughter.

Elston attended Ashton-under-Lyne Police Station.

He was arrested on suspicion of gross negligence manslaughter, corporate manslaughter and offences under the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974.

Detective Chief Inspector David Moores from Greater Manchester Police’s Serious Crime Division said: "John Graveson went to work on March 3, 2023, expecting to return home to his family at the end of the day.

“Tragically, he never did.

"This was not the result of an unforeseeable accident.

“Our investigation uncovered an alarming pattern of unsafe working practices that had become normalised on site. The risks were obvious, persistent and entirely preventable.

“Case law tells us that, for corporate manslaughter to be proven, failings must be exceptionally serious.

“The circumstances in this case met that threshold. These were failings of the most serious nature.

“Workers were routinely exposed to significant danger.

“We saw instances of vehicles reversing, skips being unloaded, and employees playing football in the same working area at the same time. It was a serious injury, or worse, waiting to happen.

“The evidence showed that management were fully aware of the risks present on site, yet failed to take the action needed to protect their workforce.

“Every person has the fundamental right to expect they will be properly protected at work and return home safely at the end of the day. On that day, John was denied that right.

“Working closely with our colleagues at the Health and Safety Executive throughout this complex investigation, we were able to expose the true extent of these failings and ensure those responsible were brought before the courts.

“Our thoughts remain with John's family, who have shown immense dignity and resilience throughout this process.

“While no conviction can undo their loss, we hope this outcome serves as a stark reminder that employers who fail in their duty to protect their workforce will be held accountable.

“Most importantly, we hope it prevents another family from suffering the same devastating loss.”

Sentencing is expected to take place on Thursday, February 4, 2027.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos