Barnoldswick businesses hit out at new pavement licence rules

4
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Changes to pavement licensing rules in Pendle will leave small businesses facing yet another cost, traders have warned.

Businesses in Barnoldswick have spoken out against the new measures being taken by Pendle Borough Council.

Pavement licences allow businesses to put removable seating outside their premises, in particular for cafes, restaurants, pubs and bars.

Pavement licences allow businesses such as cafés, restaurants, pubs and bars to place removable furniture outside their premises.

But as of New Year’s Day, businesses in Pendle will have to have barriers with metal tops and bottoms next to their tables and chairs, a decision made to help those with impaired sight.

Businesses have criticised the policy, saying the requirements may not be practical for some premises and will create another expense for traders.

Holly Townhill has owned Victoria’s cafe on Barnoldswick town square for four-and-a-half years.

Holly Townhill, owner of Victoria's in Barnoldswick. Credit: Victoria's

She raised concerns about the new policy at the West Craven committee on Tuesday, November 3.

Holly said: “That is obviously a big additional cost for a small business, but actually the practicalities behind it (could negatively affect businesses).”

Victoria's cafe in Barnoldswick. Credit: Victoria's

She said Victoria's was "fortunate" to have enough space for the barriers, but other businesses with less room outside could be negatively affected.

Holly added: “It does feel very limiting. It comes in in January, so it is coming up. And you would not believe how many people want to sit out, in the rain.

“You assume that it is a summer thing, but it isn’t for us, we have people who regularly sit out, without fail, and we would lose custom if we were not able to have outdoor seating.

“We were informed recently there was an update on the policy, as there had been a consultation.

“But a two week period for consultation is not always reasonable when you are running a business.

“It has felt like a policy saying ‘you can’t do this, you can’t do that’ but hang on, I am paying for this pavement licence, I am paying for the privilege and now you are putting further restrictions on what I’m able to do?”

She added carrying the furniture in and out every morning and evening is already ‘quite a heavy physical burden’ and the barriers would add to that.

Holly added: “Barnoldswick is very unique in that it has a town square and cafe culture, whereas town centres like Nelson and Colne are based on one main high street.

“Why on earth are places like Nelson making decisions on our pavement licences? I understand there have to be policies in place but surely there is room for a common sense solution.

“Small businesses are under so much pressure to even exist, we don’t need to be busier, we just want to pay the bills. It’s one more decision that we need to make.”

She said permanent furniture would be better as those with impaired sight would know it would be there at all times, unlike removable furniture.

Hickey’s and Friends on Albert Road, just down from the square, also puts furniture on the pavement outside.

A senior member of staff said: “I can’t see at the moment how it is going to work, it is one thing for businesses on the square but it is going to take up a lot of room on the pavement for us.

“They do look nice but it’s another expense and it’s not a great time, but what can you do?

“We have looked at buying them and when you get a quote, it is near enough a couple of grand depending on how big your outside bit is.”

They added that, with ‘two massive trees’ outside the bar, a permanent fixture would not work for them as it would take up too much room.

One other business in the area which preferred not to be named described the policy as a ‘box-ticking exercise’.

A senior staff member said: “I don’t see how it will actually make life easier for the visually impaired, as they are potentially still going to walk into the barrier like they would with a table or chair.”

Speaking on the idea of having a more bespoke policy for the town, he added: “I think that would be a good thing if they are able to use common sense.”

He also raised concern about how the rules would affect Barnoldswick Town Council, with it putting seating out on the square at various points throughout the year.

He said: “If that stops them putting those out, then it would be a very bad thing because it attracts a lot of people into the town.”

Town councillor Leanne Barrett, chair of Barnoldswick Town Council (BTC), was present at the West Craven meeting where Holly initially raised the issue.

She said BTC would have further discussions with Pendle’s licensing team about the pavement licences.

Speaking to the Local Democracy Reporting Service after the meeting, she said those discussions were pending due to the relevant officers currently being away.

Town Coun Barrett added: “In terms of the town council’s own use of the square, we would hope that the new arrangements will recognise the importance of the square being available for community use and supporting local businesses.

“The town council wants to continue making use of the space, including providing seating for residents and visitors.

“We would certainly support a bespoke and proportionate approach to pavement licensing in Barnoldswick.”

She added BTC ‘wants to see the square used more regularly by all ages’ and help support local businesses, and hoped to ‘work constructively with Pendle’.

Councillor Lola Whipp, portfolio holder for planning and infrastructure, which includes licensing, was also present at the West Craven committee.

She said the ‘cafe culture’ of Barnoldswick set it apart from other places in the area, adding the rules were ‘very restrictive’.

The Liberal Democrat councillor added the executive voted to have businesses re-apply for the licences every three years, which was the maximum allowed, rather than forcing them to do it every one or two years.

Coun Whipp added: “I think there is a need to look at it again, I will certainly look at getting it back on the agenda to revise it and to survey your concerns.”

Speaking afterwards to the Local Democracy Reporting Service, she added: “Pendle is a very polycentric place, so making policies for the whole of Pendle is a difficult task, ensuring they are good for a range of areas, all of which are very different.”

On being asked if individual policies for different areas could be implemented, she said that would not be happening.

Coun Whipp added it was difficult to make the decision at executive because the consultation did not receive ‘very many responses’.

But on hearing the point that already-busy business owners had not had the time to respond, she said: “I’d say that’s very fair. We try to strike a balance in making decisions but having a decent period of consultation.

“The policy itself is always going to be available for review if there are issues.”

Coun Whipp added she intended to ask for a review in the ‘short to medium term’ but could not give an exact timeframe as she had not yet discussed it with officers.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos