Clayton-le-Moors pub to become another shop despite campaign

3
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.
Close Icon

Find, save and share Public Notices that affect you in the area.

Search the Public Notice Portal What is the Public Notice Portal?

What is the Public Notice Portal?

The Public Notice Portal carries statutory public notices published in local newspapers and is the fastest and most effective way of finding out what is happening in YOUR neighbourhood.

Search the Public Notice Portal

A community campaign to save the Hare and Hounds Hotel in Clayton-le-Moors has failed.

Planners have approved its conversion into a convenience store, following little market interest in retaining the building as a pub.

Hyndburn Council has granted planning permission for the change of use of the vacant Whalley Road pub into a convenience store, together with a rear extension and a reorganisation of the car park, following the venue’s closure last year.

The proposal attracted significant local attention, with residents launching a campaign to save the historic Thwaites pub after its closure.

Campaigners argued that the venue remained an important community asset and gathering place.

However, planning officers said extensive evidence had been provided showing both a lack of commercial interest in continuing the premises as a pub, amid wider economic challenges that saw the Hare and Hounds’ booze sales cut in half post-pandemic.

How the new shop in the Hare and Hounds building would look.The front of the building will remain largely the same (Image: Hyndburn Council)

 The applicant submitted marketing evidence showing the property had been advertised continuously for more than 12 months from February 2025.

It was initially placed on the market for £495,000 before the asking price was reduced on three occasions.

During the sales campaign, there were 34 viewings, but officers said there was "very limited interest" in acquiring the premises for continued use as a public house despite it being offered free of tie, and last going on sale for £400,000.

Most enquiries instead related to alternative uses, including retail, residential conversion and community uses.

The planning report stated: "The evidence demonstrates that the premises have been appropriately marketed for the required period at market value and that reasonable efforts were made to secure its continued use as a public house."

Officers also accepted evidence that the business had become increasingly difficult to operate profitably.

A viability letter from former owners Thwaites said the company had struggled to secure tenants and had seen inconsistent rental income over recent years.

The former pub will be extended and its car park rearranged as part of the conversion (Image: Hyndburn Council)

 The brewery said successive operators had attempted to make the pub sustainable but had failed despite investment in the building, rental support, utility assistance and discounts designed to help compete with other venues.

Thwaites also pointed to declining beer sales, changing drinking habits and increasing competition.

Its report noted that many traditional community pubs have lost trade to home drinking, a trend accelerated by the Covid-19 pandemic.

Council officers highlighted additional financial pressures affecting the sector, including rising operating costs, increases in National Insurance contributions and higher minimum wage costs.

They concluded that the Hare and Hounds was no longer economically viable as a public house.

The report also noted that several other licensed premises remain within walking distance of the site, meaning the loss of the Hare and Hounds would not create a shortfall in local pub provision.

The approved scheme will create a convenience store with a maximum sales area of 236 square metres.

Planning documents submitted with the application state that the development is expected to create two full-time and two part-time jobs.

The applicant is Randhawa Property Group Ltd, which has previously submitted planning applications for Tesco.

However, no supermarket operator has been identified in the planning documents for the Hare and Hounds site, and the approved plans simply refer to a convenience store.

 Officers concluded that the development would provide a local shopping facility while preserving the character of the existing building.

The customer entrance will be located at the rear, with the prominent front elevation remaining largely unchanged apart from refurbishment works and new signage.

A proposed cash machine was removed from the plans following objections from Lancashire Constabulary, which raised concerns over its location and potential crime risks.

In recommending approval, officers acknowledged: "Whilst regrettable, the loss of the public house is acceptable."

It added that the submitted marketing and viability evidence adequately justified the change of use and that the scheme would provide a suitable local convenience facility without causing unacceptable impacts on neighbouring residents or the highway network.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos