52 homes in Hyndburn plan moves ahead despite 181 objections

4
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.
Close Icon

Find, save and share Public Notices that affect you in the area.

Search the Public Notice Portal What is the Public Notice Portal?

What is the Public Notice Portal?

The Public Notice Portal carries statutory public notices published in local newspapers and is the fastest and most effective way of finding out what is happening in YOUR neighbourhood.

Search the Public Notice Portal

Plans for a controversial 52-home housing estate in Oswaldtwistle have been recommended for approval by planning officers despite attracting 181 objections and opposition from local councillors.

The application to develop land west of Rhoden Road, submitted by McDermott Homes, will be decided by Hyndburn Council's planning committee on October 7, after being called in by ward councillor Steven Smithson.

The proposed development would see 52 homes built on 1.73 hectares of grazing land between Rhoden Road, Roe Greave Road and Whams Brook.

The plans include a children's play area, landscaping, drainage works and a new vehicular access from Roe Greave Road.

The site currently consists of enclosed grassland used for horse and livestock grazing and contains a stable building that would be demolished. But the plans have sparked a wave of local opposition.

The land is currently used for grazing animals (Image: Hyndburn Council)

 Residents have raised concerns about increased traffic, parking pressures, highway safety, flooding, loss of green space, pressure on local services and the impact on wildlife.

Both Cllr Smithson and fellow Cllr Gaynor Hargreaves submitted objections, while dozens of residents warned that Roe Greave Road and nearby streets are already struggling with congestion and parking problems.

When the plans first emerged earlier this year, Cllr Smithson publicly urged residents to oppose them, arguing that the area had already experienced substantial housing growth without matching investment in roads and public services.

He claimed the estate could add more than 100 extra cars to the surrounding network and expressed concerns about the scheme's effect on the character of the area.

However, planning officers have concluded that the development should be approved because the site now forms part of an allocated housing site in the recently adopted Hyndburn 2040 Local Plan.

streerosThe development has attracted over 100 objections (Image: Hyndburn Council)

 The wider allocation, known as Land off Rhoden Road/Roe Greave Road, is expected to deliver around 51 homes and was considered suitable for residential development during the examination of the local plan.

Officers say this means the principle of housing on the site has effectively already been established through the council's strategic planning process which, under a recent change in national legislation, has become a primary factor in deciding whether an application gets approved.

The site also has a history of residential planning proposals. In 2016, outline planning permission was granted for up to 34 dwellings on much of the same land, including proposals to improve Rhoden Road.

However, a reserved matters application was never submitted, and that permission was not implemented. Planning officers say the earlier approval demonstrated that housing development on the site was considered acceptable in principle.

If delivered, the Rhoden Road development would not provide a single affordable home for the residents of Oswaldtwistle.

The developer said this is because of a viability assessment they carried out, arguing that providing affordable homes or making financial contributions towards parks and infrastructure would make the scheme unviable.

An independent consultant commissioned to review the figures agreed, concluding that the development was only marginally viable.

Planning officers accepted that assessment, meaning the scheme contains no affordable housing despite local planning policies normally seeking such provision.

Accrington Town HallHyndburn Council's planning committee will rule on the development next week (Image: Anthony Moss)

Outside of the type of homes planned for the site, one of the most contentious issues with the development is the impact on local roads.

Objectors argue that Roe Greave Road suffers from narrow carriageways, on-street parking and congestion, while Rhoden Road remains unadopted and constrained.

Yet Lancashire County Council Highways has no objection to the scheme after reviewing amended plans.

Highway officers concluded that the development would not have a severe impact on the road network and that appropriate mitigation measures could address identified issues.

Proposed improvements include a new footway linking the development to existing pedestrian infrastructure, upgraded public footpaths and highway works around the site entrance.

Residents also expressed fears that new housing could exacerbate flooding problems linked to Whams Brook and drainage infrastructure in the area.

However, the council's report notes that the majority of the site falls within Flood Zone 1 and that both the Lancashire County Council Lead Local Flood Authority and United Utilities have accepted the drainage strategy in principle, subject to detailed conditions.

The scheme includes an attenuation basin designed to control surface water runoff and limit discharge rates to existing greenfield levels.

Objectors also highlighted the site's role as habitat for birds, mammals and insects and questioned the loss of grassland and hedgerows.

Ecology officers acknowledged that the development would result in habitat losses but concluded that suitable mitigation, habitat management and biodiversity enhancements could be secured through planning conditions, including a 30-year management programme.

In recommending approval, planners place substantial weight on the delivery of 52 new homes on an allocated housing site, alongside improvements to local footpaths, new public open space, a children's play area and the remediation of contaminated or potentially unstable land.

They conclude that the proposal complies with the development plan when read as a whole and that any adverse impacts do not outweigh the benefits of the scheme.

If councillors follow the recommendation, the development will proceed subject to dozens of planning conditions covering highways, drainage, ecology, landscaping, contamination and public open space.

The final decision will be made when the application comes before Hyndburn Council's Planning Committee next week.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos