Skelmersdale teacher can stay in profession despite drinking

Our lady Queen of Peace Catholic Engineering College <i>(Image: Google)</i>
Our lady Queen of Peace Catholic Engineering College (Image: Google)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A teacher at a Lancashire school can remain in the profession despite turning up for work under the influence of alcohol on two separate occasions.

The Teaching Regulation Authority held a hearing into Natalie Kelly, who used to work at Our Lady Queen of Peace Catholic Engineering College in Skelmersdale.

Allegations put to Ms Kelly, who had worked at the school since 2015, were that she was under the influence of alcohol on December 13, 2023, and June 20, 2024, and on the latter date was accused of bringing alcohol onto the school premises during working hours.

The hearing heard difficult personal circumstances at the time had contributed to Ms Kelly's drinking.

On December 13, she was said to have been slightly late for a meeting and had rushed into the room and bumped into a table.

She then spilt her cup of tea twice, and was said to seem “a little erratic”.

Another English teacher had followed her into the bathroom, who said she could smell alcohol on her and that she had been crying in the toilet.

Evidence from the report said: “In oral evidence, Witness B stated that when the meeting began, she did not think about the possibility of Ms Kelly having consumed alcohol.

"She simply assumed that she was stressed and rushed at the beginning of the meeting and needed a moment to calm herself.

“In relation to the nature of the smell she detected, Witness B was asked to opine as to whether it was fresh or stale in nature. She responded that it seemed to be fresh.”

Another witness said Ms Kelly had admitted to having drunk one and a half glasses of wine before coming into school that day.

However, Ms Kelly did not accept that she was impaired to the point of misconduct, in that she had done yard duty, taught four lessons and no concerns had been raised prior to the departmental meeting.

She also denied being ‘all over the place’ or slurring her words and identified that the witness had taken her shopping afterwards and did not seek to stop her driving home.

The report added: “Ms Kelly admitted this allegation on the specific basis that she consumed alcohol the previous evening and approximately one and a half glasses of wine that morning, before school.

“She confirmed that she was particularly struggling at the time with personal matters, which she expanded upon in her oral evidence, in relation to which she had received upsetting news the previous day, which triggered the alcohol consumption.

“The panel was persuaded that it was more likely than not that when Ms Kelly arrived at the School and began her working day, she remained under the influence of alcohol.

“There was the potential for her to be affected by it, even if Ms Kelly may have genuinely felt she was perfectly capable of performing her duties.”

On June 24, a witness giving evidence said that Ms Kelly had come to her saying she felt terrible and that she had a headache.

The witness added that it became clear to her that Ms Kelly was under the influence of alcohol because she could smell it on her.

She also alleged Ms Kelly had become uncoordinated, knocking things over and appeared to be sleepy and unable to use her phone properly.

In addition, the witness also stated that she noted there was a bottle of vodka in Ms Kelly's bag, with about a third of the contents remaining.

The teacher had to be driven home by another member of staff, and the witness also noted an unopened bottle of wine in her bag.

The report added: “She accepted that she had a setback and consumed a significant amount of alcohol the previous evening, to the extent that she was 'really intoxicated' on the morning of June 20, 2024.

“She also accepted that she drank some wine that morning. To that extent, she accepted she both smelled of alcohol and was under the influence of it.  

“Ms Kelly very candidly accepted her behaviour and that she should not have come into school under these circumstances.”

However, the panel did not find that Ms Kelly had consumed alcohol on the school premises that morning, and there was no direct evidence to that effect.

The report said: “The panel took careful account of the fact that it was recorded that Ms Kelly had health and personal issues at the relevant time and subsequently.

"However, she held a position of trust and responsibility, and she had a duty to act as a role model. 

“Ms Kelly was, fundamentally, responsible for her own actions and, to her credit, fully accepted that her actions were wrong and should not have happened.

“It was clearly unacceptable to attend work whilst smelling of and under the influence of alcohol in the manner she did.  

“For these reasons, the panel was satisfied that the conduct of Ms Kelly amounted to misconduct of a serious nature which fell significantly short of the standards expected of the profession.”

Ms Kelly was highly regarded as a teacher, and the panel said that while she was adamant she would not return to teaching, there was a positive public interest in retaining her in the profession.

The panel found that Ms Kelly had managed to navigate her way through the investigation process and it was clear she now had sustained and robust support structures in place.

They added that although she was not presently minded to do so, should she change her mind, they were satisfied she would make a positive contribution to teaching, education and the profession by using her skills, experience and expertise.

The report added: “It was clear that, at the time these events occurred, Ms Kelly did not have sufficient insight into the risks associated with her actions. 

“In the panel’s view, her understanding and reflections had clearly evolved and developed to the extent that, now, she did have that insight.  

“The panel also considered that the risk of repetition was mitigated by the passage of time, her previous and continuing rehabilitative steps, her current personal circumstances, her ongoing support structures, which were robust, and the mechanisms she stated she utilised to manage stress and challenging events.”

David Oatley, who represented the Secretary of State, said that he concluded a prohibition order was not proportionate or in the public interest.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos