Column

Has Burnham overpromised in ending homelessness pledge?

2
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Successive Prime Ministers have over-promised and under-delivered, and I fear Andy Burnham has already fallen into that trap.

He fell into the trap not only on day one, but on pledge one – ending homelessness.

While a very well-meaning policy – no one likes walking past homeless people slumped in empty shop doorways, or seeing beggars wandering between cars at traffic lights – it’s an almost certainty that he will fail.

He promised to do it in Greater Manchester, and despite spending over £5.5 million a year, he failed.

Numbers fell there between 2018 and 2021, but have gone back up since.

Providing accommodation for rough sleepers takes them off the streets, but it doesn’t solve the root causes of homelessness.

A rough sleeper (Image: PA)

Huge shortages in social housing, drug addiction, youth unemployment, mental health issues and the care leaver cliff-edge all contribute to homelessness, and many have tried, and many have failed, to fix these.

Burnham’s charisma and immediate, easy cost-of-living wins have won him some credit with the public, but his opponents have been given a stick to beat him with that he created himself.

The root causes of homelessness can’t be solved overnight, and it’s going to take at least until the end of this electoral cycle in 2029 and probably many years beyond that to find a solution, time Burnham might not have.

Blackburn with Darwen has bucked the trend on rough sleeping, seeing a 47 per cent reduction since 2021 while the national figure is a 20 per cent increase.

And this comes despite a doubling in the number of households in the borough seeking homelessness assistance in that time, which is a credit to the council.

The BwD model is something Burnham should pay attention to, something the borough’s MPs should hold up as best practice to avoid the Prime Minister trying to stick with his unsuccessful Greater Manchester model.

Blackburn with Darwen Council kept thousands of households off the streets, created almost 300 new affordable homes with nearly 200 more being built, the homeless pods in Shadsworth gave people somewhere warm and safe to sleep, and it worked with partners to try and tackle drugs problems.

Burnham’s predecessor Sir Keir Starmer, after the farcical reigns of Boris Johnson, Liz Truss and Rishi Sunak, wisely went for an under-promise and over-deliver approach, but his inability to hail success and his lack of hope proved his undoing.

Burnham has to back up his big promises, but his flagship policy may have doomed him before he’s even started.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos