Blackburn Reform UK 'track refugees' call likened to 1940s Germany

4
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

During a fiery full council meeting at Blackburn Town Hall, one motion submitted by the borough’s new Reform UK group was accused of violating international law.

The mammoth four-hour Blackburn with Darwen Council Forum kicked off with Mayor Mahfooz Hussain handing out civic awards to a number of councillors who lost their seats in May’s local elections.

In that poll, Reform picked up nine seats, having had none beforehand, making them the third largest party in the authority.

But at Thursday night’s first full meeting of the new-look council, it became apparent that the insurgent right-wing party was not done shaking things up.

Reform’s Cllr Helen Voegt submitted a motion regarding transparency around the Home Office’s accommodation programme for asylum seekers and asking if the council was keeping tabs on people who have been granted asylum, which led to one representative crying out: "It’s not Nazi Germany".

Cllr Voegt introduced the motion at Thursday night's meeting (Image: Will Morgan)

Cllr Voegt noted that Blackburn with Darwen had received £855,600 as part of an asylum dispersal grant for the last financial year, a scheme which is paid for by the government to cover housing costs and other support needs for people fleeing persecution.

Blackburn with Darwen has no so-called 'migrant hotels', and in the year ending March 2026 there were 270 asylum seekers in dispersal accommodation in the borough, which has a population of more than 155,000.

While she accepted that this accommodation was found and funded by the Home Office, in conjunction with private firm Serco, Cllr Voegt said: “Once a claim is resolved, individuals exit Serco-managed accommodation and support, at which point the council has no requirement to track their onward outcome.

“The cumulative local impact of both the temporary dispersal population and any individuals who go on to settle permanently in the borough following a grant of asylum - school places, primary care capacity, translation services, homelessness duties, and community cohesion – falls to this council and local partners to manage.”

The wording of the motion then demanded that Blackburn with Darwen be notified by the Home Office when any local housing is used to accommodate people seeking asylum, but it was a demand to track the ‘cumulative effect’ of residents who have been granted legal refugee status that caused outrage.

The meeting fell into disorder multiple times during the motion (Image: Will Morgan)

Asylum can be applied for under the 1951 Geneva Refugee Convention – an international law that was drafted and negotiated by the UK following the horrors of World War Two.

Once a court has ruled on the validity of a person's claim, they are granted refugee status for a period of five years, in which they are allowed to work and access essential services like the NHS.

After this period, they can apply for indefinite leave to remain, unless they have committed a serious offence or the circumstances have changed in their home country.

Responding to the motion, Labour's Cllr Damian Talbot, executive member for housing and public health, stressed the council itself does not provide asylum accommodation.

He added: "The very title of this motion, in my view, appears to illustrate the Reform UK group’s lack of understanding of our council services that are operated.

“As with the previous motions, it appears to be more of a series of questions that could easily have been put to officers and executive members and then responded to.

"There is and must be transparency; we are legally required to notify the Home Office of any spending.

“The content of the motion appears more concerned with the movements of those granted refugee status, people who have proven their right to live permanently in the UK and reside where they choose.”

Cllr Matchett defended the motion and refused to apologise (Image: Will Morgan)

He added: “When a person is granted refugee status, this removes all restrictions on their movements. Both within the country and abroad.

"They can choose to live wherever they want to, whether that’s in Blackburn with Darwen or somewhere else.”

Similarly, Cllr Brian Taylor (Lab) said the council was ‘proud’ of the borough’s inclusiveness, adding: “I note that this motion is targeted at the residents who have been awarded asylum; it singles them out from others who have settled in this borough.

“Do we track and trace people from Bacup, or Whitworth?”

Conservative Cllr Neil Slater claimed that the insurgent party were trying to ‘out Restore, Restore [Britain]’, in reference to the even further right-wing nationalist party set up by Nigel Farage's arch-rival Rupert Lowe.

Cllr Slater said: “I know what you’re saying and I can see where you’re trying to go with it, but it doesn’t sit well in this borough.

“We’re not Nazi Germany, we don’t put crosses on doors and swastikas. We welcome people here, we help them.”

Finishing, Cllr Slater added that he would apologise if he came over ‘too strong’, but received a round of applause from the chamber.

Reform group leader Cllr Daniel Matchett responded by saying the Conservatives ‘are living up to the uniparty expectations’ and pushed back against the claim that his party did not understand how the council works.

Cllr Matchett said that Reform’s own ‘rough calculation’ was that 4,000 people had entered the borough under the asylum dispersal scheme over the past 20 years.

He said ‘we don’t know’ the identity of people claiming asylum and calling some ‘fighting-aged males’.

Cllr Matchett said: “I’m surprised at the Conservative Party and, to be honest, the independents need to be taking stock of this too, because this is your communities.

"You don’t want undocumented males-”

At this point, the chamber erupted in outrage. Cllr Mustafa Desai, leader of the independent 4BwD group, whose members are all British Asian, called the inference ‘unacceptable’, while the mayor banged his gavel in an attempt to bring the meeting back to order.

Mayor Hussain said that members were ‘disappointed’ with the comments and wanted an apology.

“I am speaking on behalf of residents of Blackburn with Darwen only,” Cllr Matchett began, causing a pantomime response from the chamber of: “No you’re not.”

The motion was defeated, with nine votes for it, two abstentions, and 32 votes against.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos