Jury continues deliberations in Luke Harden murder trial

3
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The jury in the trial of a man accused of murdering Luke Harden has completed its first full day of deliberations and will continue considering its verdict tomorrow.

The 11-person jury at Preston Crown Court retired on Monday afternoon (May 10) after hearing the remainder of the judge’s summing-up.

Bhekisani Matabiswana, 27, of St James Square, Bacup, denies murdering Mr Harden, who suffered catastrophic head, face and neck injuries in an incident on Newchurch Road, Stacksteads, in the early hours of November 1 last year.

Mr Harden, 37, had earlier been at a Halloween party at the Rosemount Working Men’s Club and later died at the scene despite attempts to save him.

(Image: Lancashire Police)

During the trial, the prosecution alleged that Matabiswana, who was dressed as a clown for the party, punched, kicked, and stamped on Mr Harden in a “sudden, quick, and brutal” street attack, intending to cause him really serious injury.

Home Office pathologist Dr Charles Wilson told the jury Mr Harden had been the subject of a “forceful assault,” with much of the injury caused by punching and some consistent with impact from footwear, and said death was due to blunt force trauma to the head and neck.

There were no defensive injuries on Mr Harden and “no injuries of any significance whatsoever” on the defendant, the court heard.

RECAP: Luke Harden murder trial live as jury deliberations continue

Jurors also heard that bloodstains on Matabiswana’s shirt and trousers matched Mr Harden’s DNA and, according to a forensic scientist, provided “extremely strong support” for the view that he had punched an “injured and bleeding” Mr Harden, rather than only coming into contact with him while helping at the scene.

The court was told that after his arrest and release under investigation, Matabiswana searched for cheap flights and bought a ticket to Johannesburg, South Africa, before being arrested at Manchester Airport.

In messages read to the jury, he said he had “beat someone up” and spoke of “jetting” out of the country, although he later accepted parts of what he told relatives were lies.

(Image: Anthony Moss)

Giving evidence last week, Matabiswana accepted he had punched Mr Harden about five times and that his actions killed him, but said he was acting in “fear” and self-defence after Mr Harden came up close to his then-girlfriend, Natalie Chadwick, in the street and punched him in the mouth.

He denied ever kicking or stamping on Mr Harden as he lay on the ground.

Judge Robert Altham has told the jury they must reach verdicts on which they are all agreed.

The jury will resume deliberations tomorrow.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos