The defence barrister in the trial over the alleged murder of Luke Harden in Bacup says there is an “absence of evidence” that proves his client is guilty.
Iain Simkin, defending Bhekisani Matabiswana, told the jury on day nine of the trial at Preston Crown Court during his closing speech that the lack of evidence meant they were unable to reach the required standard to be sure the defendant murdered Mr Harden.
Matabiswana, 27, of St James Square, Bacup, denies murder and manslaughter, saying he acted in self-defence after Mr Harden had reached his hand towards his girlfriend, Natalie Chadwick, as they walked home from a Halloween party in Stacksteads last year.
Luke Harden (Image: Lancashire Police)
Mr Simkin said there was no evidence to demonstrate any “ill-feeling” between the defendant and Mr Harden, and no evidence of what took place as the incident was not captured on CCTV.
He also said evidence heard in court from experts said Mr Harden’s injuries could have been sustained from three punches, and there was an “absence of evidence to take you any further than three punches.”
RECAP: Luke Harden trial - Counsel give closing speeches
Mr Simkin also told the jury there was no evidence to demonstrate the marks on Mr Harden’s face had come from the shoes Matabiswana was wearing.
Nicholas Rhodes, prosecuting, told the jury in his closing speech that Matabiswana had killed Mr Harden by inflicting injuries to his head, neck, and face of “such catastrophic nature that any one or any combination caused his death".
The case so far:
Day 1 - Updates from day one of murder trial
Day 2 - Murder trial hears Luke Harden 'beaten to death after Halloween party'
Day 3 - Luke Harden trial - Jury hears audio of 999 call from scene
Day 4 - Luke Harden trial - sister gives evidence in court
Day 5 - ‘Murder’ victim died from forceful assault and blunt force trauma, jury told
Day 6 - Luke Harden trial - murder accused attempted to leave UK
Day 7 - Luke Harden murder accused says he acted in self-defence
Day 8 - Luke Harden murder accused says he intended to return to UK
He said the only way the injury to the back of Mr Harden’s head could have been inflicted was by a shod foot, something Matabiswana denies using.
Mr Rhodes said nothing else on Mr Harden’s journey from the Halloween party to where he died could have inflicted those injuries on him, and there was no evidence “until he got to the scene of his death that anyone had stamped on his face".
Preston Crown Court (Image: Anthony Moss)
He added: “It’s the one uncomfortable fact the defence has struggled with, because they know perfectly well that if you find that he did stamp at least once on his face, thereby causing really serious injury, that he’s guilty of murder.”
Both the prosecution and the defence have now concluded their cases, and the judge will continue his summary of the case to the jury on Monday before they are sent out to begin their deliberations.
The trial continues.
Share