It was the summer of 1995, and the Britpop chart war between Oasis and Blur felt like the most important thing in the world.
I was 13, at a bus stop in Walkden arguing with my older cousin Claire: I was firmly Team Oasis and Roll With It, she was backing Blur’s Country House. When Blur clinched number one, south defeating north, she was delighted and I was outraged.
That rivalry now underpins John Niven’s new play, The Battle, which opened in Birmingham last month before arriving at Manchester’s Opera House this week. Billed as a wickedly funny dive into one of rock’s greatest rivalries, it promises a nostalgic trip back to Cool Britannia.
I went in with high hopes, knowing it was directed by Matthew Dunster (The Pillowman, 2:22 A Ghost Story) and starring Mathew Horne (Gavin and Stacey) and Louisa Lytton (EastEnders). Somehow, though, it fell flat. Some of the jokes felt like they should have stayed in the 1990s, and the laddy bravado often came across as corny rather than sharp.
That is not to say there were bad performances. George Usher nails Liam Gallagher’s swagger, and Will Taylor is very funny as Blur’s Graham Coxon. The play is said to be based (mostly) on real events, and the real-life touches are among its strongest moments, including Miranda Sawyer’s Observer interview with Noel Gallagher.
Oscar Lloyd as Damon Albarn and George Ushe as Liam Gallagher in The Battle (Image: Helen Murray)
Noel’s notorious remark hoping Damon Albarn and Alex James would “catch AIDS and die” is quoted on stage, and the line clearly jarred with some in the audience. Sawyer has since said she regrets printing it, recognising how it could be read as homophobic and feed a harmful atmosphere, and the scene here underlines how ugly it sounds now.
More: I was at The BRIT Awards' first show in Manchester – this is what it was really like
More: Spellbinding ghost story with real-life Strictly couple brings chills on hottest day
Paddy Stafford as Noel and Liam, George Usher in The Battle (Image: Helen Murray)
Later, the play descends into the surreal, with Tarantino-style fight scenes and even a Take That singalong. By the end, plenty of people were on their feet, cheering and singing along, and many seemed happy to be in on the joke and revel in the nostalgia.
But for others, The Battle may be proof that some moments are better left in the 1990s.
The Battle at Manchester’s Opera House until Saturday, March 21
Share