Review

What we learned from US made Blackburn segregation report

Max Frost, RocaNews co-founder and his team were in town to speak to people about ‘segregation’. <i>(Image: Roca News)</i>
Max Frost, RocaNews co-founder and his team were in town to speak to people about ‘segregation’. (Image: Roca News)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

An American reporter took to the streets of Blackburn for an independent YouTube news channel. Here is what he found.

Host of the programme and co-founder of RocaNews, Max Frost and his team were in town to speak to people about ‘segregation’.

The Roca News YouTube channel sees reporters head to towns and cities across the world "to speak to local residents and find out what they are really thinking" and says it was established as a tonic to "biased" mainstream media.

Frost said he had been prompted to come to Blackburn after the town's MP Adnan Hussain had suggested in a news article back in September that ‘Blackburn is a racially segregated town'.

MORE: ‘Young people seemed less divided’: We speak Max Frost who made the ‘segregation’ report about Blackburn

Many of the responses in Blackburn were unsurprisingly familiar, while others, thanks to Frost’s persistence, shed light on some of the issues people are facing in the town.

He began in the predominantly Asian areas, such as Altom Street, near the Masjid-e-Raza, but was shocked to find people were a little hesitant speaking to him.

Frost said: “Nobody in this place will speak to us.

“We have never been to a place ever where we have left without an interview.”

He says the only way to ‘demystify places was through conversation’.

It appears residents are rightly wary and have become a little more media savvy knowing how reporters in the past have headed north to get their 30 seconds of footage with a pre-determined narrative.

One man said: “There are reasons. We get a lot of media people coming here. What the media do is paint a very bad picture.”

But thankfully, later he does speak to a number of people.

He incorrectly assumes that ‘it was worth noting here that many people don’t speak English’.

An old man on a park bench says in Urdu that he finds people living in the town ‘are very good.’

One pleasant surprise was Frost asking questions in Urdu, which was probably a revelation for the interviewee as well as those watching. If there ever way to dispel myths, then speaking and understanding another language is certainly one of them.

Another British-born man who is of Indian descent says, when asked about segregation: “We have our little pockets. Now it is expanding because of the children.”

He adds: “Sooner or later we won’t have them pockets because we will all be one.

“You respect every religion. If an English person comes here as a Christian, wherever it is, you respect their religion. We want it likewise.

“We are not segregated. A white person is more than welcome. It is not us who moved away, but it is the white community that moved away from us.”

The man adds he thinks if an Asian person of family moves into a predominantly white area, "alarm bells start ringing and they think, 'it's time to sell up'".

He added the town's Asian community is "close knit" and there for each other, reflected in the large funeral crowds frequently seen.

Frost notes the area "feels like a real community where everyone knows everyone".

The RocaNews YouTube channel sees reporters head to towns and cities across the world (Image: RocaNews)

Frost then heads into the town centre, which he strangely describes as "the English part of town", and goes on to describe as "dying", adding "many people are drunk or on drugs".

White people he speaks to all say the town is getting worse, before touching on its industrial heyday and subsequent decline.

One man he speaks to outside a town centre pub says: “I am not racist, but the Asians are buying everything up.”

Another says the town feels divided, while another (wrongly) claims there are no pubs in the town centre anymore, and agree the town feels segregated but there is no animosity from them about this.

Another says: “Pubs, bars - people used to come from Manchester and Liverpool in coaches to Blackburn.

"Then all the pubs shut and all the nightclubs shut. It’s a dead town now.”

He later makes a bizarre claim, caveated that he's "not a racist person", that "a lot of Asian councillors coming into the council and they don’t like pubs and shut them down," whereas the main reason businesses shut is lack of trade.

The man appears to ignore the glaring fact that the cost of running small pubs up and down and country has sky-rocketed, with hundreds of pubs and clubs closing.

Another couple outside Wetherspoon in Darwen Street make the factually incorrect claim ‘free speech is dead’ and claim to ‘know people who had got arrested’ for speaking out.

It is left to a young man to put things in perspective.

He tells Frost, “We are all human. We are all people at the end of the day. Wherever we come from, whatever we are into. What we have grown up understanding.

“I have grown up with people who are Muslims, but I don’t see them any different to myself.

“Just because they practice another faith or religion does not mean they cannot be my best friend on the weekend, and I would expect that from anyone else.

"Northern spirit, if you will.”

Another young man adds: "We mix different cultures in classes and there's no problem, we all get along, we're all united as one."

He then speak to an elderly man, outside another town centre pub, who says: "They have their own culture which is fair enough, but they don't want to integrate."

He then talks glowingly about the Shia march but admits some people "resent it as it's an alien culture", before adding: “The Asian community think the English don’t have a culture. They think English is fish and chips.”

The man who appears to be nice enough but would be surprised to learn the Asians he speaks of are actually ‘more English’ than some of their neighbours.

Frost then heads into The Lion pub and finds out more about how a pub can be a focal point for local communities.

A man says: “It is a community place for people to come and meet each other."

He adds there's a pub nearby where people - he reels off a list of several nationalities - meet up and all get along "as a close-knit friendship circle" but that there's other areas were this doesn't happen.

He later says: “Some parts of the community don’t want to integrate, whilst others do want to and have done," and ponders in a very measured manner on the reasons why this could be.

He adds that Britishness to him is to do the best to improve the lives of everyone around him.

Frost concludes by retelling his conversation with a Pakistani man who was sat in one pub, who told him, “There is segregation, but there are a few people on both sides who are trying to make it work and mix together, and that is what it is all about.”


Verdict

Of course, we may not like what some people may say. We may also find some of their answers a little naïve.

None more so than a conclusion, which appears to suggest that the pub may be the answer to Blackburn’s segregation issue.

The fact, and one that is hard to ignore, is that segregation only appears to be an issue when it comes to Muslims. It has been a common theme.

It is unlikely that the same could be said of an Italian quarter, a Chinese quarter or, for that matter, a Jewish enclave.

It also appears to be less of an issue for people living in a place than for someone else.

So, whilst some people want to defend their town, others will wish to find reasons for failures and may blame their neighbours.

Some of the content might not be comfortable viewing for people living in the town, but on the whole, Frost makes a genuine attempt to speak to people from different backgrounds. Not always an easy task.

The report highlights how some misconceptions are clearly helping to grow the divide and others who are keen to share the positives.

He can, of course, only speak to those who are willing to speak to him, and it would have been easy to pick and choose only people who make ‘good TV’.

I think more of an effort to visit some community centres or even local businesses may have helped, or the many places in town where even the suggestion of ‘segregation’ makes you sound like you are from another planet.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos