Blackburn GP has suspension overturned in High Court

The former Umar Medical Centre in Bastwell, Blackburn <i>(Image: Archive)</i>
The former Umar Medical Centre in Bastwell, Blackburn (Image: Archive)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A Blackburn GP who was suspended from the UK medical register has had it overturned by the High Court.

The decision came after it found the tribunal which sanctioned her had applied the wrong test for dishonesty.

Dr Sarah Alam, a senior GP partner at the former Umar Medical Centre in Lime Street, Blackburn, had been facing a three-month suspension after a medical practitioners' tribunal ruled she had dishonestly changed patient records.

The tribunal had ruled Dr Alam had retrospectively altered 14 patient records in April 2018, recording verbal invites for chronic disease reviews which “she knew to be untrue.”

However, on appeal, the High Court found ‘errors of principle’ in the tribunal’s approach, adding that it had applied an ‘inconsistent’ measure for dishonesty.

The appeal was brought by Dr Alam’s medical defence organisation, MDDUS, on two grounds: the dishonesty principle and what it argued was the tribunal’s ‘reversal of the burden of proof’.

The former Umar Medical Centre in Bastwell, Blackburn (Image: Archive)

Mr Justice Jarman said the tribunal had failed to ‘stand back from the minutiae’ and take an overview of the dishonesty allegations.

He also noted that it had accepted that many other entries were made honestly.

Counsel for MDDUS, Andrew Colman, argued the tribunal’s findings implied Dr Alam would have switched between honesty and dishonesty within minutes of making different entries.

Justice Jarman said it was also an error not to consider Dr Alam’s previously unblemished character, supported by testimonials from colleagues who spoke of her ‘honesty, competency and patient satisfaction’.

On the burden-of-proof issue, the court found that Dr Alam had been given ‘the benefit of the doubt’ by the tribunal on one occasion, which implied that this benefit was withheld elsewhere, which would amount to reversing the burden of proof.

The High Court quashed the finding of impairment and the suspension on the first ground. 

READ MORE: Wheelchair-bound builder wins permission for £1m ‘life-changing, Grand Designs’ home

READ MORE: East Lancs woman takes home top prize at Female Business Awards

READ MORE: Teachers to walk out in row over school's virtual maths teacher

Lily Lloyd, lawyer at MDDUS, said: “We welcome this decision, which provides a sensible and fair outcome for our member. 

“We’re pleased that the court accepted the submissions made in support of Dr Alam, and we’re proud to have supported our member through what has been a difficult and stressful process.  

“We remain committed to providing firm, dependable support to doctors facing regulatory proceedings.”

Dr Alam said: “After six challenging years, I’m deeply relieved at the positive resolution.

"I’m profoundly thankful to my exceptional legal team, my wonderful colleagues, and my dedicated family for their steadfast support. 

“I’m now eager to get on with caring for my patients and serving the community as I have always aspired to do.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos