Blackburn man stole Rolex after faking banking app payment

2
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A man stole expensive goods, including a Rolex watch, after fraudulently disguising himself as a legitimate buyer.

Shane McDonagh, 27, showed both of his victims a screenshot of a fake banking app when purporting to be transferring the money for the goods.

When it became apparent to the victims that McDonagh was not a legitimate buyer, he would become angry and assault them.

The first victim was Eduardo Lopes, who listed a computer graphics card for sale for the price of £2,100.

Preston Crown CourtPreston Crown Court (Image: Anthony Moss) McDonagh messaged Mr Lopes under the name Samuel Jones, and they agreed to meet at a Tesco store in Addlestone, Surrey, on January 3, 2022, with McDonagh having travelled from Northolt in north-west London.

The two met, and Mr Lopes, still believing at the time that this was a legitimate transaction, handed over the card before the money had arrived.

He asked McDonagh to wait, and when pressed about where the money was, McDonagh became “agitated and aggressive” according to prosecutor Thomas Bramhall.

He told Mr Lopes the payment had gone through, so “it was his problem now.”

Shane McDonaghShane McDonagh (Image: Lancashire Police)

Another male, found to be working with McDonagh, then approached the pair and asked what was going on.

He followed them into an alleyway, at which point Mr Lopes was punched in the face around 10 times.

At this point, a crowd of residents had come to see what was going on, and McDonagh was walking away, telling them he had paid for the item.

Mr Lopes reported the incident to the police, and McDonagh was arrested more than a year later, in April 2023, having been picked out by Mr Lopes at an identity parade.

READ MORE: Man denies attempts to cause grievous bodily harm

READ MORE: Man to stand trial after denying strangulation and assault

The second victim was Christopher Robinson, from Preston, who had listed a Rolex watch for sale on Facebook Marketplace which McDonagh said he was interested in, under the name Tom.

McDonagh and another man went to Mr Robinson’s house and conducted the same scam they had on Mr Lopes.

They had agreed on a price of £10,500 for the watch when McDonagh showed him the fake screenshot of the banking app sending the money.

McDonagh even went as far as pretending to phone his bank, leaving the kitchen where they had been discussing the transaction so he could do so.

When he came back in, he became angry and told Mr Robinson: “We’re leaving with the watch with your face smashed in.”

Mr Robinson realised he was not going to get it back so allowed them to leave, but kept the paperwork for the watch and phoned the police.

McDonagh was located and told officers he had only been there to verify the authenticity of the watch.

This offence was committed while McDonagh was on bail from Guildford Crown Court for the first offence.

The watch has since been recovered.

Simon Hustler, mitigating, said some remorse had been expressed by McDonagh in his pre-sentence report, though the author of that report admitted they were not sure how deep that remorse ran.

McDonagh, of Meadow Street, Blackburn, pleaded guilty to two counts of theft, and single counts of fraud, assault occasioning actual bodily harm, and common assault.

Judge Phillip Parry, sentencing at Preston Crown Court, said: “You have left a devastating impact on your victims by the way you treated them and threatened violence against them.

“You minimised your involvement in both sets of these offences. You have very low victim empathy. You are assessed as having a high risk of harm to the public.”

McDonagh was sentenced to three-and-a-half years in prison.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos