Ribble Valley debate on party swap councillors facing by-elections

6
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

With Reform UK making political headlines and taking control of Lancashire County Council, the topic of councillors changing their political parties or group affiliations without standing in a by-election has been debated at Ribble Valley Council.

Stephen Atkinson, the former Conservative leader of Ribble Valley Council, swapped to Reform UK earlier this year and, following his county election win this month, looks likely to become the next leader of Lancashire County Council. He remains a borough councillor too.

But in the past year or so, a number of Ribble Valley borough councillors have swapped political parties or moved from one group to another without borough by-elections being held to gain a fresh mandate for them from voters. Changes in councillors’ political affiliations are allowed by law – but can also prompt debate or comment from others.

Other Ribble Valley councillors to have swapped allegiances over the past year or two include Lee Jameson, Nicholas Stubbs, Lee Street, Derek Brocklehurst, Mark French and Ryan Corney.

As a result, a range of political parties and groups have seen gains and losses at Ribble Valley Council including Labour, Lib-Dems and the Conservatives. New groups have also been formed too, such as Progressive Liberals and, separately, growing numbers of Independents.

Changing affiliations and by-elections were discussed during questions at the latest full Ribble Valley Council meeting.

Opposition leader Labour Coun Michael Graveston asked questions to the council’s deputy leader, Conservative Coun Simon Hore, who is currently the acting leader. For clarity, Stephen Atkinson was not present but had sent his apologies, as had some other missing councillors.

Coun Graveston asked: “Does the deputy leader believe that councillors who defect and change party affiliation or resign from political parties should face a by-election?”

Independent Coun Jim Rogerson quipped, saying: “Half of the council  has just left the room.” This raised a few laughs among councillors.

Responding to the question, Coun Hore said: “You ask what I believe, as acting leader. Currently there is nothing in the law that prevents councillors from switching affiliation between political groups or parties once elected, or deciding to have no political affiliation and switching to be an independent. We therefore must accept this.

“The decision is a matter for the individual councillor who, no doubt, will decide based on their local party or national issues at the time.

“The broader issue is not for me or this borough council. It can only be led by a change in the law by MPs at Parliament, who exercise the same right to switch political affiliation – and many have done so over the past century or more.”

READ MORE: 'Genuine worry and fear' for county council after Reform UK victory

East Lancs results key to Reform UK's county council landslide

Then Coun Graveston said: “I’m inclined to agree. But what if a councillor has said publicly in the media that others should resign or stand in a by-election if they switch affiliations but then later changes their own affiliation?”

Coun Hore said: “It makes life difficult. Integrity at all levels of government is important.  It makes it particularly difficult when people put things in the press.

“If it ever happened to me – and I’m not moving to any other party – then I’d feel it necessary to resign my seat. But I’m not moving party.”

Earlier in the meeting, Coun Hore spoke about Stephen Atkinson’s recent switch. He said: “Last month brought the unexpected resignation of the leader. I was personally saddened over the loss of Coun Atkinson after six years as leader and achieving so much.

“However, we move on with an agreed budget for 2025-26 and the highest capital budget this council has ever seen. It is not for us to be distracted from this council as our first priority.  I will remain deputy leader until a new leader is elected by the council in May.”

His capital budget reference related to some big spending plans for the next two years or so. These include affordable housing work in Longridge and other areas, and investment in Ribblesdale Pool and Clitheroe Castle. Some spending was brought forward because of an expected shake-up of local councils by 2028. This could include mergers or abolition of some councils.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos