- Mobile site
- E-Newsletters
-
- News feed
- Find us on Twitter
@lancstelegraph
News, sport and entertainment from all over East Lancashire
@blackburnrovers
All the latest news from Blackburn Rovers
@burnleyfc
All the latest news from the Clarets
@lt_blackburn
Latest news from Blackburn
@lt_burnley
Latest news from Burnley
@lt_darwen
Latest news from Darwen
@lt_hyndburn
Latest news from Hyndburn
@lt_pendle
Latest news from Pendle
@lt_ribblevalley
Latest news from Ribble Valley
@lt_rossendale
Latest news from Rossendale
- Find us on Facebook
The Lancashire Telegraph
News, sport and entertainment from all over East Lancashire
Telegraph manager poll: Your verdict on who should take over at Blackburn Rovers (From Lancashire Telegraph)
When news happens, text LT and your photos and videos to 80360. Or contact us by email or phone.
Telegraph manager poll: Your verdict on who should take over at Blackburn Rovers
10:10am Thursday 4th October 2012 in News
By Andy Cryer, Blackburn Rovers reporter
Ian Holloway is your first choice to take over as Rovers manager
BLACKBURN Rovers supporters have sent an emphatic message to owners Venky’s in their search for a new manager with vastly experienced bosses topping the Lancashire Telegraph readers’ poll.
More than 700 votes were received in the space of two and a half days on who the club should target to succeed Steve Kean in the Ewood Park hot seat, with the results showing a strong call for a more established figure to guide Rovers back into the Premier League.
Blackpool’s charismatic boss Ian Holloway led the way with more than 20 per cent of the vote, with former Wolves man Mick McCarthy a close second with 17.5 per cent.
Former Spurs chief Harry Redknapp (6.8%), Real Madrid’s old boss Bernd Schuster (5.6%), ex-Charlton and West Ham number one Alan Curbishley (5.3%), Huddersfield’s ex-Rover Simon Grayson (4.9%) and Spaniard Rafa Benitez (4.2%) also featured in the top 10.
A lack of experience appears to have worked against Rovers’ Premier League winning skipper and the club’s apparent initial favourite, with the Tottenham technical director Tim Sherwood just receiving 1.4 per cent of the vote.
Former Manchester United ace Ole Gunnar Solskjaer received strong support towards the end of the poll, after it was reported he would be interested in the role, with a late surge taking him to joint fourth in the vote with 5.6%.
The 39-year-old is on the verge of taking Norwegian outfit Molde to their second successive title, having previously managed Manchester United reserves for three seasons.
Former Ewood darling Alan Shearer was one of the few to buck the ‘experience’ trend. He proved the most popular ‘legend’ to return as manager with 4.9% of the vote, while 3.5% felt caretaker boss Eric Black should be handed the reins.
With Rovers yet to start the process to find a new manager in earnest, the Lancashire Telegraph poll provides just an early snapshot of what supporters are feeling, with a wide range of names suggested.
New names are coming into contention all the time but the initial feeling among Rovers supporters appears to be that a wily old campaigner should be given the top job, with the club having suffered under managerial novice Kean over the past two years.
YOUR VERDICT
1 - Ian Holloway: 20.8% (148 votes)
2 - Mick McCarthy: 17.5% (125 votes)
3 - Harry Redknapp: 6.8% (49 votes)
4 - Bernd Schuster: 5.6% (40 votes)
5 - Ole G Solskjaer: 5.6% (40 votes)
6 - Alan Curbishley: 5.3% (38 votes)
7 - Alan Shearer: 4.9% (35 votes)
8 - Simon Grayson: 4.9% (35 votes)
9 - Rafa Benitez: 4.2% (30 votes)
10 - Eric Black: 3.5% (25 votes)
Also voted for: Kenny Dalglish (22 votes), Keith Hill (22), Tim Sherwood (10), Paulo Di Canio (10), Glen Hoddle (10), Garry Flitcroft (8), Michel Salgado (7), Billy Davies (5), Karl Robinson (5), Jurgen Klinsmann (5), Graeme Souness (5), Tugay (4), Henning Berg (4), Paul Dickov (4), Gary Neville (4), Steve Bruce (3), Christoph Daum (2), Ally McCoist (2), Roy Keane (2), Colin Hendry (2), Frank Rijkaard (2), Mike Newell (2), Phil Neville (1), Henrik Larsson (1), Iain Dowie (1), Slaven Bilic (1), Walter Smith (1) and Micky Mellon (1).
Comments are closed on this article.

Comments (108)
10:16am Thu 4 Oct 12
Crow27 says...
Yo-yo McCarthy
Curbishley
Black
Redknapp would come.
For me, it would be Holloway or Ole.
10:25am Thu 4 Oct 12
NickH1982 says...
Shuster for me.
surely Mcarthy didnt get that many votes
10:26am Thu 4 Oct 12
cathedral citi says...
Young and dynamic, he is hungry for success!
Give him a chance!
10:31am Thu 4 Oct 12
StephenKean says...
10:38am Thu 4 Oct 12
b12simon says...
10:39am Thu 4 Oct 12
kazz says...
10:44am Thu 4 Oct 12
Ryanb74 says...
10:47am Thu 4 Oct 12
Rovers1975 says...
My 1st choice would be be Benitez. High profile and straight out of the top draw. Still lives pretty local and might just be ready for a new challenge.
10:51am Thu 4 Oct 12
Captain Dreckley says...
10:56am Thu 4 Oct 12
French Rover says...
Black is still second fav with Tim Sherwood slipping out to third. You can still get Holloway at 33-1 (so he is not coming) and Benitez is way out at 40-1 surprisingly.
So get your money on the Ole the former Red while you can....he looks tied-on for it now.
11:08am Thu 4 Oct 12
cassidyboom says...
11:09am Thu 4 Oct 12
hassy rvr says...
11:12am Thu 4 Oct 12
woz1974 says...
11:15am Thu 4 Oct 12
Tatts says...
11:16am Thu 4 Oct 12
Road Runner Road Runner says...
OGS would be my choice pick of the bunch although B Scuhner is a very interesting prospect.
Holloway I would say is not a contender ?
Young, energetic and ambitious with a great track record in the game surely must give him the edge over say a Sherwood ?
Arte et labore
11:19am Thu 4 Oct 12
woz1974 says...
11:31am Thu 4 Oct 12
ewood1952 says...
11:38am Thu 4 Oct 12
stefjam says...
11:39am Thu 4 Oct 12
Jansen_10 says...
Cryer's banging the McCarthy drum - but we want stability and good football!
OGS would be great. Redknapp would be incredible (but it wont happen due to location) and Pep Guardiola would be a dream come true!
More realistically, Schuster is a good shout
11:50am Thu 4 Oct 12
French Rover says...
11:55am Thu 4 Oct 12
formerover says...
12:13pm Thu 4 Oct 12
Riverside 7 says...
I would be pleased with either of the above.
Please don't give it to Black or McCarthy.
12:23pm Thu 4 Oct 12
1simon_garner says...
needs someone who can stand up to Vankies and not be a yes man!
12:36pm Thu 4 Oct 12
Brunzig says...
12:39pm Thu 4 Oct 12
woz1974 says...
oes he know anywhere north of watford gap ??
12:40pm Thu 4 Oct 12
bburnrover says...
Glen Hoddle is the best of that bunch an intelligent tactician who quietly gets on with it.
Harry Redknapp also great man manager similar to Terry Venables not frightened to leave people out but good in the transfer market but can we afford him and Joe Jordan?
Holloway is a bit erratic at times but is always interesting so yes he will be good.
No to McCarthy he stood there match after match watching Wolves lose and did not have a clue how to remedy it bit like Black last night not a great tactician but a nice guy always honest but not up to the job,
Keane has also failed to deliver and should not be considered as he has an arrogant abrasive nature which we cannot afford at Ewood.
All the ex players -big no as none have broke any pots yet.
Mark Hughes- Why would he leave a top club to rejoin us? Pity he was a great boss.
Solsjar - He may be the man we should go for but would he come here? Young and hungry with an excellent track record.
12:41pm Thu 4 Oct 12
sonny says...
Holloways a weirdo and McCarthy's just a boring safe option.
12:47pm Thu 4 Oct 12
glp says...
12:48pm Thu 4 Oct 12
woz1974 says...
12:54pm Thu 4 Oct 12
A Darener says...
12:58pm Thu 4 Oct 12
roverfor60years says...
If that is not done, it really doesn’t matter which manager is brought in. Either he would be just another puppet – or he would pack his bags as soon as Mickey and his friends started poking their noses in. Either way they would be back where they started.
Bringing in players behind the manager’s back is madness.
1:05pm Thu 4 Oct 12
revjon says...
At least it won't be you know who.
1:14pm Thu 4 Oct 12
moh says...
1:38pm Thu 4 Oct 12
woz1974 says...
1:46pm Thu 4 Oct 12
zenoufthebirdcatcher says...
2:06pm Thu 4 Oct 12
RoversSwiss says...
Spoke to a Wolves fan, said McCarthy was terrible, various reasons. He said they have taken 28 million pounds from sales, spent 3 million. The parachute payment already in the back pocket. What would have happened at Rovers if Venkys had done that!
Surprised not more votes for Hill and Grayson.
Whoever they employ will be a risk, don't want another coach turned manager.
2:10pm Thu 4 Oct 12
Wild Rover says...
He has got to be our man...
Mind you they said he would be better than Sam, look where that got us
I think our next manager is already with us...
2:23pm Thu 4 Oct 12
roverfor60years says...
2:29pm Thu 4 Oct 12
French Rover says...
One thing for sure the decision won't be Black and White - nor Black and Shearer either....maybe Black and Decker?
2:39pm Thu 4 Oct 12
stick to football says...
No one who is appointed will have been the first choice of everyone but we have got to learn to trust that they will get it right (one cant change the past but must look forward with optimism)
Rightly the fans have been carping for so long many have forgotten the good days at Ewood but they can return just dont expect an instant run of victories.
Howver we are well placed and a win on Saturday will put the smaile back on many faces.
2:40pm Thu 4 Oct 12
BJS says...
2:48pm Thu 4 Oct 12
blueblooded says...
NO TO MCCARTHY, BLACK, SHERWOOD, SHEARER, BERG or KEANE.
Redknapp wont come.
2:58pm Thu 4 Oct 12
handyamBRFC says...
I don't think we should go for a small league manager as we are a bigger club and hopefully bound for the Premier league.
I know many individuals are being bandied about...!!
I wouldn't bet against a Scottish manager as there's many about.....!!!
OK.......but how about.........
Graeme Souness
knows the game, has the contacts, influential & strong.
been there and done it as a player and manager
Gordon Strachen
similar to above......
knows the game, has the contacts, respected man.
been there and done it as a player and manager
Derek Fazakerly
ex player, coached at higher levels in the game
know BRFC very well......!!!
3:08pm Thu 4 Oct 12
handyamBRFC says...
a German or someone from or with experience in Europe ...
A German as long as they bring the German mentality....!
A European as long as they bring along the flair.....!!
and sorry but no southerners....i mean eastenders...londene
rs....!
they dont understand football above Watford gap.........TRUE.
Its sad to say, we dont really have any Lancashire lads who know the game and have the experience of managing a top club.
3:15pm Thu 4 Oct 12
earwego says...
3:16pm Thu 4 Oct 12
Is Eckersley playing? says...
3:21pm Thu 4 Oct 12
oreilly21 says...
OGS would be a good choice also, he has done well in Norway and now is right time to step up to this level. a good relationship with United is no harm either.
The calls for Keith Hill are worrying me, his win percentage of 28% with Barnsley doesn't say to me he has the ability to get us promoted.
SImon Grayson would be a great shout also. he has done well everywhere he has gone.
Roy Keane would a high profile name and would bring some good discipline and direction to the club
3:22pm Thu 4 Oct 12
benal13 says...
!!!
3:39pm Thu 4 Oct 12
ROVERSCAN says...
The Venks dont want to spend any money, and the names mentioned in your pole aint gonna come without a few quid in the pot to buy there own players, Its not hard top work out SIMPLES!!!!!!!!!!
3:57pm Thu 4 Oct 12
Sam-the-Man says...
!
So after 9 months Black never felt strong enough to have a quiet word with Gollum (sorry I just refuse to use his name) or he agreed with everything that was happening.
So either way that’s a no, no from me. He may, one day, make a fantastic manager but his actions (or lack of) prove to me he is not the man we need right now.
Pay Redknapp £1M for the next 9 months add a £2M bonus if he gets us promoted. In the meantime we can look for someone who can take us further once this has been achieved.
Let’s face it Redknapp won't need to move home because he know the job is only till next summer and if he doesn’t get us promoted then we are in the brown stuff for a long time, so £3M is small price to pay.
3:59pm Thu 4 Oct 12
Sam-the-Man says...
3:59pm Thu 4 Oct 12
jogalot says...
4:06pm Thu 4 Oct 12
jogalot says...
I can only see Harry taking the job if he was promised money to spend. He can wheel and deal but I can't see him trading any of the squad and getting great players in exchange. And if he is promised money he will only leave Rovers in debt and with more financial problems that they already have, imho. He has a track record of leaving clubs in the lurch. Spurs managed to get rid before got the chance.
4:29pm Thu 4 Oct 12
FannyTickler says...
4:49pm Thu 4 Oct 12
ronnie clayton says...
5:00pm Thu 4 Oct 12
pbirty says...
5:09pm Thu 4 Oct 12
DirtyHarry says...
.co.uk/sport/footbal
l/teams/blackburn-ro
vers/9585438/We-shou
ld-not-be-too-surpri
sed-by-the-idea-of-a
-Venkys-Roy-Keane-do
uble-act-at-Blackbur
n.html
Oh please let this be true, I would laugh so hard I'd need surgery! The circus begins again!!!!!!
5:48pm Thu 4 Oct 12
MatthewCA says...
All the above names are not applied, they all are waitng near to there telephone with there BIG EGO. none of the listed ex-managers strongly come out to help - for last two matchs.
We need one experianced BOSS who can manage , control , build players and support FANS on the ground, not in the board room.
There is surely a big lobby running around the city and in venky's head also. make sure venky will fullfill the demand with the fans. But Fans always choose the BIG NAMES , but they will fail in this championship hardwork part. we don't need fashion show , we need to win the game.
6:03pm Thu 4 Oct 12
Rovers1975 says...
6:08pm Thu 4 Oct 12
jimmyth38 says...
6:27pm Thu 4 Oct 12
burnleyglentoran says...
Why would he want to take a step down!!!?
BRKFC - JUST A LAUGHING STOCK NEAR SHADSWORTH!!!!!!!!
6:28pm Thu 4 Oct 12
willhelmrover98 says...
Benitez
Ole
Holloway
Then Redknapp. (but he wouldnt come.) :(
6:29pm Thu 4 Oct 12
ewoodsaythat says...
6:42pm Thu 4 Oct 12
hugofakenham says...
6:42pm Thu 4 Oct 12
Ovais789 says...
Uu the way did nobody vote Tugay?
6:52pm Thu 4 Oct 12
azza234 says...
6:57pm Thu 4 Oct 12
Is Eckersley playing? says...
Chuck your hat in the ring!
7:06pm Thu 4 Oct 12
smellthecoffee says...
7:07pm Thu 4 Oct 12
goldfinger59 says...
7:13pm Thu 4 Oct 12
RUinsane says...
7:29pm Thu 4 Oct 12
ROVERSPAL1 says...
THEY DO HAVE THE RECORD BUY FOR THIS CLUB..
My choice would be M.Salgado very good links with Real the only player to tell Samba off when he made silly mistakes, very passionate about the game, played under some great managers.. knows the area knows the club and talks sense when he is a pundit for Spanish football .. AND will have enough ambition to do well because one day he wants to go back to manage REAL ..
7:30pm Thu 4 Oct 12
Bryan Douglas supporter says...
7:43pm Thu 4 Oct 12
merlinrabbit says...
7:46pm Thu 4 Oct 12
merlinrabbit says...
7:47pm Thu 4 Oct 12
kazluvsrovers says...
We have got our new manager now and if we win on Saturday it will be
confirmed next week.
Venkys are a business and are only interested in making money they don't care about the feelings of the fans, once they have squeezed us dry they will sell us on and move onto their next venture.
Eric Black is here to stay!!!!!
7:53pm Thu 4 Oct 12
DirtyHarry says...
DirtyHarry wrote:
http://www.telegraph
.co.uk/sport/footbal
l/teams/blackburn-ro
vers/At least you'd only have to slightly alter the banners, the chants could stay the same, and would probably be heard after his first match in charge.
The Venky's really don't like you lot do they?
8:09pm Thu 4 Oct 12
jellybiff says...
8:21pm Thu 4 Oct 12
fudgingluvrovers says...
8:41pm Thu 4 Oct 12
noddy57 says...
t holloway hes far too busy at bpool,,and the rest are pretty average too,,,come on shebby pass on the message,,
8:43pm Thu 4 Oct 12
bring back the good old days says...
No for me it went something like this;
"I need to warn/advise you (Walker trust) that I cannot be sure that these would be good owners for BRF., Yes, I know the fit and proper test has been passed, but basically that test is just horse shoite". "I agree I don't own the club as you do, but I feel I have a responsibility to Jacks memory and the common supporter".
"OK so what you're saying is, you really don't care owt for the club, as Jack did, and you want the readies, no matter who's paying".
"Ok if you say so, I will sit in and see how it goes and if and when things don't seem quite right, I will be looking to offer my services elsewhere as I would not want to be part of anything destructive to BRFC".
IMHO.
8:49pm Thu 4 Oct 12
Ewood say that! says...
Personally,I just hope it's anyone but Eric Black.Having said that I'll still go down and cheer the team on regardless!!
8:53pm Thu 4 Oct 12
Dr Zinc says...
Who the hell voted for Black ! (the backroom staff)
Have people learned nothing ?
Why woud we want anyone from the SK debacle ? who is on Kentaro's books
Why would Venkys want someone from the same stable as SK
I hope im wrong but I fear it will be Black and what will that tell us of the ownership of Blackurn Rovers ?
As for Holloway and Mcarthy: baffoons the pair of them
9:18pm Thu 4 Oct 12
RUinsane says...
10:01pm Thu 4 Oct 12
stony bloke says...
10:13pm Thu 4 Oct 12
ossybsting says...
10:22pm Thu 4 Oct 12
ossybsting says...
10:28pm Thu 4 Oct 12
ossybsting says...
10:43pm Thu 4 Oct 12
Tatts says...
11:13pm Thu 4 Oct 12
jonjonweatherman says...
11:18pm Thu 4 Oct 12
Stone Island: says...
11:20pm Thu 4 Oct 12
Stone Island: says...
11:25pm Thu 4 Oct 12
Stone Island: says...
11:39pm Thu 4 Oct 12
Stone Island: says...
The Venky's are despicable, and dishonourable people. They, and they alone, are responsible for the utter shambles that this once proud football club has become.
12:22am Fri 5 Oct 12
Bryan Douglas supporter says...
12:23am Fri 5 Oct 12
Stone Island: says...
In 2001, we paid £8M for Andrew Cole (cash). An initial fee of £4.5M has been paid for Rhodes, rising to a POSSIBLE £8M depending on certain factors, one of which is promotion this season. Highly unlikely, with these jokers in charge.
5:23am Fri 5 Oct 12
whappen says...
It looks as though we are not alone when it comes to having barn-pot owners.
Have you noticed how the journos have forgotten all about the "dignity" cr@p and are starting to have a bit of a go at Kean? And they're really laying in to Venkys. Some have even dared to suggest Kean's appointment may have been "influenced" by something other than his suitability for the job. They sound like they are testing the water; just seeing what they can get away with before someone has a quiet word.
We told you but you wouldn't believe us would you? Feel free to print a double page apology to all the Rovers' fans you slated last year.
I hope they do actually know something definite but just haven't been able to prove it yet. Hopefully it will all come out in the wash.
Manager? Of those mentioned, I'd say OGS sounds the most interesting. The rest? They're mainly high risk, soiled goods or flights of fancy. Or just not good enough, plain and simple.
Like the guy in the Telegraph says, Venkys would get more money selling tickets for the interview with Roy Keane than they would on a Saturday. I'd have one for sure.
5:32am Fri 5 Oct 12
whappen says...
Spartans down to 7999 then.
6:49am Fri 5 Oct 12
kiwipom73 says...
....lot depends on what th deal is with te Venky, and this guy Singh and how he fits into the set-up.
...if the Venky,s have not learnt from the Anderson/Kean experience they will go cheap ....and go Black.
...Singh could be a BIG setback if he is going to be sticking his nose into signing players and team matters !!!
...I also think that SCHUSTER and SOLSKJAER before any others
...OUTSTANDING AND WITH MUCH TO PROVE PLUS GREAT LONG TERM INVESTMENT (although Sherwood with a quality assistant would be a likely good move...)
IF THE VENKY,S - SINGH ARE WISER AFTER THE TWO YEARS SOAP OPERA AND SERIOUS ABOUT THE CLUB AND IT,S FUTURE THEN WE ARE ABOUT TO FIND OUT VERY SOON.
7:55am Fri 5 Oct 12
A Darener says...
8:17am Fri 5 Oct 12
ronnie clayton says...
11:51am Fri 5 Oct 12
Rovers1975 says...
1:12pm Fri 5 Oct 12
noddy57 says...
9:50am Sat 6 Oct 12
revjon says...
11:30am Sat 6 Oct 12
damo10 says...
Must be his extended family, because i can't see what appointing him would acheive?
We need a fresh start, new ideas tactics, fitness levels etc, that gets the fans excited enough to want to part with there hard earned cash!
Giving job to Black would NOT acheive this.
11:34am Sat 6 Oct 12
damo10 says...
5:04pm Sat 6 Oct 12
juanbbien says...
12:15pm Sun 7 Oct 12
handyamBRFC says...
Mick Mcarthy - thick as pig ****.....talks crap.....!!
Roy Keane - thick and inept at managing
likes to spend loads of money buying crap players
he needs to be managed himself but hes difficult & silly
kenny dalglish - 'Past it'
....lacks motivation, only good for 6 months at most
prefers to play golf, likes others to do all the work
& prefers to sit asa director and get paid for nothing.
Ian Hollaway - thick and talks crap
just about manage a pub team
lucky manager but not acceptable for a premiership team - BRFC
5:17pm Wed 10 Oct 12
shimmy says...