COMMENT: Rovers MUST get this decision right (From Lancashire Telegraph)
When news happens, text LT and your photos and videos to 80360. Or contact us by email or phone.
COMMENT: Rovers MUST get this decision right
11:00am Thursday 11th October 2012 in Sport
By Andy Cryer, Blackburn Rovers reporter
THE first question any manager will ask Venky’s with regards the Ewood Park hot seat is surely ‘will I be allowed to manage things my way?’.
Rumours of interference on signings and team selection over the past couple of years will hardly fill any potential applicants with confidence.
They shouldn’t either. Shebby Singh – who it appears has been given the ultimate responsibility of finding a new boss for the owners – has got a massive decision to make in the next couple of weeks.
I don’t think it is over-exaggerating by saying it is probably the biggest decision facing the club since the Jack Walker era began, maybe even before that.
Once Singh has made that though, it is imperative he allows the chosen one to be his own man, with regards all the on-field aspects. Anything else simply won’t work.
That is why it is so important they know exactly who they are employing. There is no point in appointing a manager who conflicts with Venky’s own ideas as it will only end in disaster.
There is also no point in appointing a manager who is going to get upset by Singh’s own blunt statements as, by his own admission, he will continue to be the club’s biggest critic if things are going wrong.
A managerial shortlist will be finalised today and we can only hope the right people have been spoken to and the right people listened to.
I genuinely believe the club has been landed in the mess it is in because the owners listened to some shocking advice and knew no better other than to believe it.
They bought the club without any knowledge of football so it stands to reason they would have no clue about what decisions to make to help Rovers move forward.
The advice they received that Sam Allardyce should get the boot was mad, the advice to appoint Steve Kean was even madder.
The likes of John Williams tried to tell them that at the time but were simply ignored into submission. Now, they have to have learned from their mistakes. Listen to the wrong advice again and we may as well all give up.
At the end of the day though, the final decision is down to them and them alone.
The past two years has been Venky’s fault because THEY made the wrong decision.
Now is the time to get it right. Now is the time to talk to ‘football people’. The likes of Derek Shaw and Paul Agnew, who have worked in the English game for years, need to have their input and need to be doing all they can – with Singh – to steer the inexperienced owners in the right direction.
But don’t be surprised to see them take their time over this because the future of the club depends on them getting it right. A scary sentence if you consider their past mistakes.
Comments are closed on this article.

Comments (106)
11:08am Thu 11 Oct 12
A Darener says...
And the answer...Of course..... (NOT)!!!!!
11:11am Thu 11 Oct 12
RoversSwiss says...
There seems to be enough experienced candidates interested in the job, quite a few should do a good job. He wouldn't be my choice, but I have a feeling Shearer will get the job, he's the only one to make it known publicly that he wants the job.
He's our best ever player and a legend, but I have doubts he will make our best ever manager.
11:14am Thu 11 Oct 12
A Darener says...
11:22am Thu 11 Oct 12
bypass06 says...
At the start of the season, nearly everyone said that we should walk this league
Whoever we had as manager. So maybe Venky's are thinking the same.
Judan Ali's name is cropping up quite a bit, and i can see them going for this option,
with Shebby "grooming" him.
11:30am Thu 11 Oct 12
blue12 says...
some debris so the Ist team coaching staff going forward will be just as vital.
11:30am Thu 11 Oct 12
tiojo says...
11:32am Thu 11 Oct 12
ewood1952 says...
11:34am Thu 11 Oct 12
ronnie clayton says...
Alan Brazil to Hendry --"Colin who do you think is best person to be manager at Rovers now ?"
Hendry replies --"The man in the job right now , he TICKS all the boxes , he is the best man".
Alan Brazil -- The last 3 results have not been very good.
Hendry replies -- Me and Eric did everything we possibly could to get a result against WOLVES but it did not work.
So they did everything they could ,Black and Hendry to get a result against Wolves but it did not work , sounds to me that is basically the same thing as saying you cannot do the JOB.
Also the words Hendry used this morning "Black ticks all the boxes" are exactly the same words he used when talking about Steve Kean just before he got his job as defensive coach at Rovers he said about Kean "Steven ticks all the boxes and the majority of Rovers fans are fully supportive of him" then lo and behold A FEW WEEKS LATER HENDRY GETS APPOINTED AS DEFENSIVE COACH .
I SUPPOSE HENDRY WITH HIS BACKGROUND WOULD SAY "THE TEA LADY TICKS ALL THE RIGHT BOXES TO BE MANAGER AT ROVERS" IF IT MEANT HIM KEEPING HIS JOB.
11:46am Thu 11 Oct 12
Marconi says...
I believe any manager worth his salt, would tell THEM, that he would only COME on condition that he managed his way
11:52am Thu 11 Oct 12
1riversider says...
This total shower in charge of OUR club have got EVERYTHING wrong from day one. Does anyone have any faith in them getting this decision right?
Anyone care to bet that the next manager will be the cheap option, and/or a client of a certain agent?
I fear for OUR club - we seem to be on a downward spiral with no escape whilst these incompetents have anything to do with BRFC.
SHYSTERS GET OUT OF OUR CLUB
11:54am Thu 11 Oct 12
hotpot8200 says...
11:55am Thu 11 Oct 12
makaveli96 says...
A lack of discipline is why the world is like it is today.
11:56am Thu 11 Oct 12
makaveli96 says...
12:01pm Thu 11 Oct 12
dallydally says...
12:03pm Thu 11 Oct 12
makaveli96 says...
Dare you to name him.....tig your on!!
12:05pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Marconi says...
12:07pm Thu 11 Oct 12
noirbrook says...
12:10pm Thu 11 Oct 12
bburnrover says...
The best applicants are the hungry for success younger guys with a track record like Hill.Hollowar,Ole Gunnar etc etc its a waste of time looking at Keane Souness and McCarthy as they are not hungry manager's and are jaded in my opinion.I am sure Glen Hoddle is the right guy as he has been away and has an appetite to get back into football management again.
12:13pm Thu 11 Oct 12
A Darener says...
Unfortunately he won't be in football management, he would be in a circus. Along wih all the other clowns.
12:18pm Thu 11 Oct 12
1riversider says...
12:39pm Thu 11 Oct 12
thetop5 says...
The test will be which manager he appoints, and most fans cannot even agree on that - Shearer, yes or no?
12:45pm Thu 11 Oct 12
ronnie clayton says...
Maybe the question is what candidates is he NOT the agent for ?
12:46pm Thu 11 Oct 12
J.C - Rishton says...
Come on Andy - are you taking the pi$$ ???
Derek Shaw who has overseen one of PNEs worst collapses EVER in its proud history and (even worse) Paul "I'm a life-long Rovers fan" Agnew - who was complicit in the criminal conspricy from the outset (he can sue me if I'm wrong but HE was involved with SK and JA in a meeting in India 3 months BEFORE Venkys bought the club) to have Venkys buy the club AND front for "other owners" AND complicit in the move to sack SA and replace him with SK (complicit BEFORE the actual take-over had been completed).
Christ on a bike - if we're relying on Shebby Singh, Shaw and Paul "worst Rovers fan in our 137 year history" Agnew then we are DEFINATELY screwed, good and proper.
Venkys please put the club up for sale NOW - yes it might take a few years to sell but the club simply cannot survive much longer under your disasterous tennure.
12:47pm Thu 11 Oct 12
greenscreener says...
When was the last time you got a comment from ROBERT COAR, as a Director of the Club, I'm sure we would all like to hear his opinion ?
12:58pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Wild Rover says...
1:01pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Wild Rover says...
1:15pm Thu 11 Oct 12
J.C - Rishton says...
Infact, the meeting is well documented so it would be interesting if Andy Cryer actually asked Paul Agnew WHY both he (who was simply "BRFC press officer" and Steve Kean (3rd coach to the 1st team) at that time, WHY they flew to India with JA (who did have a reason for attending the meeting as he was THE nominated "advisor" to Venkys) - but WHY were Kean and Agnew as in India for the meeting ????
1:46pm Thu 11 Oct 12
bluerob says...
Shebby, please contact John Williams, apologise and pay him what ever it takes to get him back. Then let him appoint a new manager and run the club the way a football club should be run.
2:06pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Harwoodstblue says...
2:15pm Thu 11 Oct 12
A Darener says...
2:25pm Thu 11 Oct 12
RGB31405 says...
Just how obscure is their search?
The qualifies candidates are obvious.
Groan...
2:32pm Thu 11 Oct 12
J.C - Rishton says...
And I'm sure it was just a COINCIDENCE that that man (Steve Kean) had Jerome Anderson (a man also at that meeting in India) as his agent.
I'm sure it was also just a COINCIDENCE that the 3 assistant managers, who all served under SK were all Jerome Anderson clients (Jensen, Clement and Black).
I also think its just COINCIDENCE that (at least) 4 if not all 6 of the Portugese signings this summer were made through a Portugese agent with links to Jerome Andersons Portugese office - although, personally, I think thats just a COINCIDENCE !
And its funny - the more you delve into things that have happened at BRFC over the last 2 years the more you keep triping over this one word - COINCIDENCE - how very bizarre !!
Still, I'm sure thats just COINCIDENTAL.
2:38pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Rovers1975 says...
Hoddle was chatting with Brazil aswell this morning and he would be without doubt a top draw manager at Rovers. I won't hold my breath. Times ticking by and I dread to think what those sh1t bags have up their sleeves.
2:44pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Bryan Douglas supporter says...
My money is on the Indian 'Coach' getting the job with Shebby being promoted to Director of Football - Mrs. D. keeping it in the family, so to speak. Shebby will do what he is told, along with Shaw and the invisible man, Agnew.
PS: It's Thursday; have they drawn up their short-list yet?
2:55pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Harwoodstblue says...
I fully believe something dodgy has been going on this last two years, hence the silence of Venkeys' ( still ongoing ) and the ' disappearance' of Anderson.
2:56pm Thu 11 Oct 12
edmy says...
3:04pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Harwoodstblue says...
3:22pm Thu 11 Oct 12
ronnie clayton says...
WHY SHOULD J.A. GET A CHUNK OF THE WAGES THAT GET PAID TO BLACK /HENDRY AND PROBABLY ALL THE PLAYERS FROM THE SOUTHERN LAND THAT IS FAMOUS FOR SARDINES , A NEW BROOM SWEEPS CLEAN.
A COMPLETE AUDIT ON WHO AT ROVERS IS THERE BECAUSE OF J.A.
3:22pm Thu 11 Oct 12
ronnie clayton says...
WHY SHOULD J.A. GET A CHUNK OF THE WAGES THAT GET PAID TO BLACK /HENDRY AND PROBABLY ALL THE PLAYERS FROM THE SOUTHERN LAND THAT IS FAMOUS FOR SARDINES , A NEW BROOM SWEEPS CLEAN.
A COMPLETE AUDIT ON WHO AT ROVERS IS THERE BECAUSE OF J.A.
3:22pm Thu 11 Oct 12
makaveli96 says...
3:28pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Harwoodstblue says...
3:28pm Thu 11 Oct 12
BJS says...
3:30pm Thu 11 Oct 12
J.C - Rishton says...
However, that said BRAG did finish each meeting (PL, FA and sports minister) with the words "We are happy to give you time to investigate whats in this document and we know it will take some time but we will NOT accept a cover up. If you don't expose these people in time then we will, by making the file available to the general media".
I will also say that the Sports minister has also acted upon the document and that the govt (and I can't stand tories) won't allow any corruption in sport to be swept under the carpet.
That said - I know BRAG have acted (and still act) in a proper manner, allowing the authorities time to investigate but time is running out and I personally feel if nothing has progressed by the end of this year then BRAG should consider exposing their evidance in January through the English media.
3:43pm Thu 11 Oct 12
madrover says...
3:44pm Thu 11 Oct 12
noddymcleod says...
3:52pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Harwoodstblue says...
3:53pm Thu 11 Oct 12
A Darener says...
4:04pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Harwoodstblue says...
4:19pm Thu 11 Oct 12
ronnie clayton says...
HAS BLACK ANY PREVIOUS SUCCESS AS A MANAGER --- NO TICK
HAS BLACK GOT A TEAM PROMOTION --- NO TICK
HAS BLACK DID WELL AT ROVERS SINCE BEING MANAG.---NO TICK
IS BLACK GOOD WITH THE MEDIA /FANS --- NO TICK
HAS BLACK GOT A DECENT ASSISTANT --- NO TICK.
HENDRY says that Black ticks all the boxes , would someone ask HENDRY ,What actual boxes is it that BLACK TICKS ?.
I THINK THE ONLY BOX THAT BLACK WOULD TICK , WOULD BE THE BOX ASKING , WILL HENDRY STILL HAVE A JOB IF BLACK IS MADE MANAGER .-------------------
--------------------
Owen Coyle ticks more boxes that they two , Coyle a non drinker .a honest man /not a natural liar ,for some it seems to come easy, Coyle who at least left his previous club with some dignity ,not like the Colin Hendry`s drinking pal and best mate , Steve Kean who after getting us relegated he is now in the process of suing Rovers.
4:29pm Thu 11 Oct 12
A Darener says...
4:34pm Thu 11 Oct 12
givet82 says...
4:36pm Thu 11 Oct 12
ElseFred says...
4:36pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Rovers 1495 says...
4:38pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Harwoodstblue says...
4:41pm Thu 11 Oct 12
givet82 says...
4:43pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Harwoodstblue says...
4:46pm Thu 11 Oct 12
givet82 says...
4:49pm Thu 11 Oct 12
ghost of sceptic says...
4:49pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Harwoodstblue says...
4:54pm Thu 11 Oct 12
greenscreener says...
4:58pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Harwoodstblue says...
.Get your facts right and you won't make yourself look a fool.
5:20pm Thu 11 Oct 12
YarkshahRover says...
5:36pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Prophil says...
5:41pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Harwoodstblue says...
6:23pm Thu 11 Oct 12
madrover says...
6:52pm Thu 11 Oct 12
kazz says...
6:54pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Harwoodstblue says...
6:58pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Arthur Labore says...
7:01pm Thu 11 Oct 12
ronnie clayton says...
Inside knowledge !
7:04pm Thu 11 Oct 12
gleechy says...
They have no hold on what the new owners do with a club that used to belong to them. They were told like everybody else that the new owners were very wealthy and wanted the best for the club, why should they not believe this?
You are just fogging the issue of how nasty these owners are. The real issue lies at the FA and Premier league who snuggled up to these liars and allowed them to be fit and proper in their eyes.
Even now after two years of suspicion they can't bring themselves to attend games, they couldn't give a hoot about the club, as long as their money is recovered, and it probably is.
7:07pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Harwoodstblue says...
7:52pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Come the Revolution says...
8:03pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Fyrover says...
8:10pm Thu 11 Oct 12
CheltRover says...
8:17pm Thu 11 Oct 12
CheltRover says...
8:29pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Nuttall Street says...
8:32pm Thu 11 Oct 12
CheltRover says...
8:48pm Thu 11 Oct 12
alphajono says...
8:57pm Thu 11 Oct 12
alphajono says...
9:17pm Thu 11 Oct 12
P888HOW says...
9:18pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Mr Purple says...
I hope BRAG is wrong but fear they could be right. Even so I want to concentrate on the positives, not on circumstantial evidence.
We have bought a good young player in Jordan Rhodes. (for a lot of money) - FACT
By hook or by crook we have also seen the end of kean. - FACT
Now whilst I shudder at the appointments of Agnew, Shaw, & Singh, at least there is someone actually administering at last.
I can't help but be excited in anticipation of who our next manager will be and I am eager to see what (whoever it is) does with this undoubtledy talented group.
I've witnessed a lot of Rovers managers and whoever it is, a new chapter is beginning for our club.
If I owned the club it would be Benitez. It won't be him, so whoever it is won't be my choice, but hey ho I don't own the club.
COYB
9:20pm Thu 11 Oct 12
whappen says...
9:27pm Thu 11 Oct 12
silverstan says...
9:34pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Mr Purple says...
9:39pm Thu 11 Oct 12
modan says...
ia Dortmond and some Premiership Clubs whom pays less than £2 million..So Venky must be serious of getting BRFC back in the Premiership where they belong.So many are linked with BRFC vacant managers post.Redknapp,Benite
z,Roy Keane,Shearer,Sherwo
od and many more.Why waste a lot of money why not hire people like Grayson,Pearson,Hill who have experience in Championsip league.
9:51pm Thu 11 Oct 12
roverinmanchstr says...
You must be on some kind of drug...The favourite ,apart from Black' is Norman No-one- knows- me...You'd better believe it !!
9:54pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Dchampy says...
I'm hearing Trappatoni is a strong contender - but there again Sven was going to join us in '96 as a proven European manager......and that didnt happen, just like Zidane didn't come - so even in JW's day we had promises that didnt turn in to reality.
OGS/Baby faced assassin for me.....
9:55pm Thu 11 Oct 12
255.255.255.0 says...
9:56pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Rovers1975 says...
9:56pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Rovers1975 says...
10:11pm Thu 11 Oct 12
roverinmanchstr says...
10:15pm Thu 11 Oct 12
French Rover says...
Now we can concentrate on the football again and getting back to the prem!
Well done Rovers - a sound footballing appointment.
10:17pm Thu 11 Oct 12
ronnie clayton says...
I would say its now 99.9% definately SHERWOOD .
GOOD LUCK TIM .
Get rid of the rest of Kean`s drinking chums ,they will drag you down , and lets all move forward.
10:32pm Thu 11 Oct 12
Brfc24138931 says...
10:56pm Thu 11 Oct 12
proud burnley lad says...
11:09pm Thu 11 Oct 12
kiwipom73 says...
Venky,s MUST allow a completed sweep-out of the old coaching staff related in any way to the Kean era....and a new team/Manager in, with your full support / backing....no interference....ALL VERY SIMPLE IF YOU ARE SERIOUS FOR SUCCESS !!!
8:52am Fri 12 Oct 12
bburnrover says...
9:09am Fri 12 Oct 12
forever blue and white says...
I assume you will be boycotting if Sherwood gets the job
Some of the Rovers supporters are pathetic
9:19am Fri 12 Oct 12
A Darener says...
But we must geet in quick before Bolton steal a march on us. As for Burnley their best bet is to go for a well known manager, infamous even. May I suggets a man who can easily get them to Euro championship leve within 2 years. His name Steve Kean.
9:24am Fri 12 Oct 12
forever blue and white says...
At the time there could have been more obvious captains (Shearer, Hendry)
Therefore somewhere along the line he must be able to get his team together and work for each other.
Maybe we should at least give him a chance before we start slating him
I would rather give Sherwood a go than the merry go round of failed managers!
9:27am Fri 12 Oct 12
Harwoodstblue says...
Next time I would look for someone with more experience to put my trust in.
9:29am Fri 12 Oct 12
stick to football says...
Why does it take them 13 days to draw up a short list if they know who they want?
Just get it sorted - or do they just love the publicity - while saying absolutely nothing
9:33am Fri 12 Oct 12
FannyTickler says...
12:02pm Fri 12 Oct 12
makaveli96 says...
Send out the rumour Sherwood will be manager, then LAY the bet!
Easy money
7:33pm Fri 12 Oct 12
Dingle Infiltrator says...
Baldy sh*its his pants, slashes the odds and when it wins he tries to knock you. And then runs a series of adverts telling us all he's "been giving us value for 40 years".
And that is because he is a c*unt.
FYI so is Tim Deadwood. A real piece of filth. Hope you get him !!
7:49pm Fri 12 Oct 12
Dingle Infiltrator says...
You are wrong.
The first question any manager will ask Venkys is: "Has somebody cleaned out the toilet since Kean left, because I don't want to walk into a lavatory which is smeared top to bottom in Kean's dried liquid ****"
Get your facts straight