Blog: Today's society (From Lancashire Telegraph)
When news happens, text LT and your photos and videos to 80360. Or contact us by email or phone.
Blog: Today's society
2:03pm Tuesday 1st May 2012 in Sir Bill Taylor blog
By Sir Bill Taylor, Lancashire Telegraph blogger
Is our Society organised? Is it organised around values that you can “buy in to”?
Is our Society civilised? Do you believe in the notion of “Society”? You will recall we had a relatively recent Prime Minister who proclaimed & professed that there was “no such thing as Society!”
The current incumbent, of course, has his “Big Society”.
But aren’t there some values that we would subliminally support, almost without question?
Wouldn’t we all agree that all our children, those of the Prime Minister or the poorest of our citizens, should have equal access to the best possible health services when they need them?
Wouldn’t that principle be extended to education too? And isn’t that too a matter of national interest?
Don’t we need the best possible education system open to all? This may mean different, because (do we agree?) different learners need different styles of education, training & learning.
But shouldn’t each & all of our children have equal access to the best possible education experience that best suits them?
Can we now embrace these notions of consensus around principles that we can agree we can share? Housing?
Do we agree that we should strive to provide the best possible & affordable accommodation for families & individuals?
Can we agree the basic amenities that should be standard?
Double glazing, central heating, some safe outdoor space, bedroom space that ensures a due level of dignity & privacy?
Law & order. Are there certain things we would agree are wrong?
Any assault on another or others? Theft? Any unlawful abuse or exploitation of the vulnerable by the comparatively strong?
Are you with me so far? And I don’t mean do you agree with me – but are these identified areas of social existence or interaction around which we can or should strive to reach a consensus?
The right to vote? Not something my soon to be 86 year old Mum had at birth in 1926.
Does the right to vote come with the duty to exercise your democratic privilege? I say privilege, as this right is not available universally to all people in every country in our shrinking world.
About 1/3rd of us vote in local elections, 3/4s in Generals.
Should going to vote be compulsory, with the right to actively abstain, as is the case in some modern democracies?
The right to free speech, freedom of expression? Do we agree that everyone should have the right to total freedom of speech, unconditionally?
Should everyone have the right to express themselves in poems, plays or prose as they see fit, uncensored?
Should our Press, or probably better now, the Media be open & free, with no notion of monopoly control, where whatever their beliefs, people are free & encouraged to express themselves?
This feels (to me, at least) to be starting to get a little more tricky? What do you think?
The right to practice, follow & express one’s Faith?
The UK can generally be described as following generally Christian principles, values & traditions, can it?
Yet disagreements about how to do just that has resulted in war & the removal of Kings (& their heads!) Going back centuries, we have always had people of other Faiths living & thriving amongst us:- Jews, Hindus, Muslims, all the world religions.
Do we agree that tolerance & respect for diversity in Faith is something that, as British people, we all share in that sense of fair play?
Isn’t it “typically British” to stick up for the under dog?
Some of us are married, some of us are not. Some of us are homosexual, some of us are not. Some of us are very religious, some of us are not.
Some of us would say live & let live, some of us wouldn’t!
So, where does that leave us? Can we leave all these issues to sort themselves out?
Do we need some processes to steward these matters through to consensus? If & when reached, do these things need some form of refereeing/policing?
Told you it probably wasn’t going to be easy!
Comments(4)
Sir Bill Taylor
says...
10:25am Wed 2 May 12
Wisdom tells you not to put a tomato into a fruit salad.
Some great points here Kevin.
My two are approaching/just reached 30. Doing OK. The only school report comment I recall is when one of them was described as a "kind child". Seems good to me.
I don't think our schools are geared up/will be "Ofsteded" upon to teach thinking...seems ike a basic skill to me.
I do some vol work with students at Lancaster Students Union. A great group of "can do" young people.
They are learning two things our society/economy need: organisation & leadership. Not always included in their degree! I don't care if they are running a political or sports club or evening the Scottish Dance Society!!! As they are learning & sharpening organisation & leadership skills...Get on!!!
Sue Lee
says...
10:34am Wed 2 May 12
Is that why you lost your seat all those years ago?
From where we stand you did a lot, improved things.
But were your thought patterns too complex for some?
Sir Bill Taylor
says...
1:58pm Thu 3 May 12
I would guess lots of people in the public eye aren't necessarily entirely wysiwyg.The teams I led made great strides in education, access for citizens to engage (Venkys pls note) & regeneration.There are those who feel they have the insight & the right to be pretty abusive towards & about those putting their heads above the parapet. I guess I am probably too sensitive, but I will live with that.
Kevin, Colne says...
6:43am Wed 2 May 12
Some good questions there, that are worthy of serious and thoughtful debate. But let me pose, if I may, another thought.
It seems to me that we’ve fallen into hyper-consumerism and elevated personal rights so that both have become an article of faith. I often wonder what our country and society would be like had the political class and the electorate chosen a different route: citizenship and human responsibilities. I cannot help but think we’d be in far better shape economically, socially and culturally.
In terms of education we’re headed in the wrong direction completely, and have been for years. In the West education is based on knowledge and skills with our clueless political class and media commentariat focused on output grades, which is fine up to a point but what about passing down to the next generation some wisdom? In many places in the East, as far as I can judge, they used to focus not just on knowledge but they tried to convey wisdom. Knowledge without wisdom is not much good.
A classical example of our national stupidity is the focus on grade outcomes in subjects taken by pupils in high schools: the really important grade is not whether you managed to get an A* in a subject – the grade that matters is your effort. If you have A* in the effort column and D in the output column you can hold your head high.
When my children were at high school I had to remind them constantly: you were not put on this earth in order to strive to meet some arbitrary performance outcome set by dozy politicians. All I’d like you to do is to try your very best, and whatever the outcome will be fine by me.
And here’s the real gem: trying your best is something that everyone can strive for regardless of background, income or social class.
We’ve taken so many wrong turnings that we’ve lost totally any sense of direction of how to get back to a better world.
The current set of political leaders are beginning to flirt with ideas that look promising but these are simply add-ons to the existing dominant ideology not the fundamental reorientation that one can rally to.
With every good wish
Kevin