Letter: Electoral system by the back door

Have we ever had a worse crop of politicians than the present lot, both nationally and locally?

Last week we had the shambles of reforming the House of Lords which everyone agrees is essential, but the proposals pushed by the Lib Dems don’t make for an improvement.

Firstly, it is suggested that 80% of members would be elected following party lines, no doubt resulting in a duplication of the Commons, with the usual party whips. Who needs that?

Secondly, they will be elected by PR, but didn’t we vote against this system? It seems the Lib Dems are going to get PR. through the back door – and I thought it was all about democracy. After seeing how the Coalition works, where a minority party has more power than its share of the vote warrants, this is an arguement against PR.

Why Cameron didn’t form a minority government so we could have poltitions who didn’t abandon their principles is beyond me. Perhaps that is too much to expect from politicians and their lust for power.

Then we had Milliband spouting about having more but smaller banks. Perhaps he isn’t old enough or wise enough to realise that we had those in the past, only for them to be taken over by larger banks.

Does he propose to introduce legislation prohibiting takeovers? But then he has to appear to be following Brussels’s dictat.

Maybe we could reduce the numbers on the local council by two-thirds and make them serve two years, avoiding having to make workers redundant. I won’t hold my breath.

J Duckworth (via email).

Comments(3)

Izanears says...
4:31pm Mon 23 Jul 12

You never spoke a truer word J Duckworth. Unfortunately, the situation won't get any better because there are too many with vested interests.

mavrick says...
7:28pm Mon 23 Jul 12

You asked if we ever had a worse crop of politicians than this lot. Well sadly we have, It was the last so called Labour administration, I have never seen so many people abandon their principals to jump on the Blair and Brown pocket lining bandwagon. The last government was not a labour government, I hadn't much faith in Ed Milliband but he seems to be getting some fight in him. I was a lifetime labour man. But this last lot sickened me. However this lot are bad for other reasons.
People need to let the politicians know what our priorities are and not theirs. If they do not deliver we should have the right to recall them and replace them in needs be.
As for the Brussels diktat Beware of Cameron's attempt to stitch the nation up with his version of a referendum.

Kevin, Colne says...
3:58pm Tue 24 Jul 12

We have no shortage of politicians, what we are lacking is statesmen.

Governing is exceedingly difficult and all the more so when you consider the appalling low standards of political journalism discourse in some parts of the mainstream media.

You see, we’ve had three to four decades of the political class fashioning people into consumers rather than citizens; and the dreadful results of this are now plain for all to see. Ironically, the rise of consumerism has played a large part in the withering and emasculation of political parties.

All of the mainstream parties are now struggling and being consumed by the monster that they helped to create. In some ways it’s poetic justice.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree