Elderly Clitheroe woman lay in the gutter outside hospital for 30 minutes as she waited for ambulance (From Lancashire Telegraph)
When news happens, text LT and your photos and videos to 80360. Or contact us by email or phone.
Elderly Clitheroe woman lay in the gutter outside hospital for 30 minutes as she waited for ambulance
11:16am Friday 28th September 2012 in News
By Vanessa Cornall, Crime reporter
A widow lay in a gutter outside a hospital for 30 minutes – only to be driven 300 metres to its urgent care centre when an ambulance arrived.
Gladys Shepherd, 81, from Clitheroe, had to wait while paramedics were dispatched from Altham, seven miles away, despite her granddaughter asking for medical help at Burnley General Hospital.
Her family, who have lodged a complaint, said they were disgusted at the indignity the grandmother-of-eight suffered after she fell in the hospital grounds.
Gladys slipped as she waited for her heavily pregnant granddaughter Louise Woods to bring her car to the entrance of Maple House, part of the hospital complex, after an appointment at the East Lancashire’s memory service.
On hearing her grandmother’s cries for help, Louise ran back to the entrance but was unable to lift Gladys back to her feet.
Louise, 26, of Brownlow Street, Clitheroe, said: “I ran inside the hospital for help.
“Three receptionists came running out with umbrellas but said there were no doctors available to check her over before moving her, so I would have to ring an ambulance.
“My Gran was literally left lying in the gutter in the rain.
“I couldn’t believe it. You would think a hospital would be the best place to have an accident, but oh no.
“We tried holding umbrellas over her and I took off my coat to cover her but she was still in a puddle.
“I even told them I would push her myself around to the urgent care centre in a wheelchair if someone would just help me get her off the floor.
“Surely you would have thought they would have spared a doctor for two minutes rather than wasting all those resources on sending an ambulance.”
After calling for an ambulance twice paramedics arrived to help Mrs Shepherd shortly before 2.30pm.
The mother-of-four had facial injuries as well as severe bruising to her legs, shoulder and arms.
Louise said: “The paramedic literally drove us the 300 metres to the hospital entrance which I could easily have walked.
“The way she was treated is disgusting. Even when we got to the urgent care centre things didn’t improve. We were left waiting for hours and my frail gran was left to sit in her wet clothes. She was still in her wet clothes when she got home five hours later at 7.30pm.
“Gran has been really shaken up by the whole incident and is now wary about leaving the house. She is literally covered in brusies. My family is making a formal complaint. It is the indignity she had to go through that makes all of this so much worse.”
Russ Mclean, chairman of Lancashire’s patient voices group, said: “I was very concerned to learn of this lady’s experiences.
“I am worried to learn that common sense has not prevailed on this occasion and that she and her family have been further distressed as a consequence.
“The urgent care centre staff should have been contacted directly by the receptionist in question or the receptionist should have called 111 - the staff there would, I am sure, have been able to offer more appropriate advice.
“Patients have a right to be treated with respect and dignity. These are fundamental rights which underpin the NHS constitution.”
A spokesperson for Lancashire Care NHS Foundation Trust, which operates the East Lancashire’s memory service in Maple House at Burnley General Hospital, said: “The staff within our Memory Assessment Service quickly reacted to this, providing blankets, gauze and umbrellas to shelter the lady involved. If there is a possibility of a head injury or risk of fracture, it is not advisable for them to be moved until they have been assessed by an appropriate medical professional.
“Our nursing staff stayed with the lady and her granddaughter until the ambulance arrived.”
A spokesman for the North West Ambulance Service said: “A 999 call was received following reports an elderly lady had fallen outside Burnley General Hospital.
“The nearest available emergency ambulance was dispatched to the scene which, at the time, was in Altham.”
Lynn Wissett, Deputy Chief Executive and Chief Nurse for East Lancashire Hospital Trust, said: “The Trust can confirm that we have now made contact with Mrs Shepherd’s family and we are currently investigating the issues that have been raised.”
Comments are closed on this article.
Comments (27)
11:39am Fri 28 Sep 12
Is Eckersley playing? says...
12:11pm Fri 28 Sep 12
Heretical says...
bly
But the nearest free ambulance was at Altham? And they are cutting ambulance services even more to make savings. Whoopee!
Just how many civil actions against the NHS is it going to take before some bean counter in government realises that it's actually cheaper to have beds and staff on hand.
That is of course if you can afford to take a civil action out....perhaps a class action like they do in the US might be on the card at some point.
12:37pm Fri 28 Sep 12
chris283 says...
12:48pm Fri 28 Sep 12
chris283 says...
12:49pm Fri 28 Sep 12
Fire Fly says...
I have to say i'm quite confused...the granddaughter says Maple House is only 300 meters from the Urgent Care Centre, She herself says she could run (despite being heavily pregnant) & quotes two occasions where she did. She even said she could push her grandmother in a wheelchair . So why, if staff were so ineffectual in helping Mrs Shepherd...did she not go to Urgent Care herself to ask for help?
And once in Urgent Care...why didn't she insist Mrs Shepherd was helped out of the wet clothes or indeed...do it herself because I would have done. I wouldn't stand by while I felt my grandmother was badly injured enough to warrant immediate assistance & I certainly wouldn't sit there for 4hours while she was in wet clothing & then drive her home in them.
Rightly so a complaints been made for the delay in help coming, you can & should expect help to be there immediately given where this happened but its quite another to standby when you could do something to help the situation if you feel its not good enough & to then complain about those things.
12:53pm Fri 28 Sep 12
chris283 says...
1:05pm Fri 28 Sep 12
Fire Fly says...
1:07pm Fri 28 Sep 12
happycyclist says...
1:19pm Fri 28 Sep 12
mavrick says...
But as has been pointed out that the cuts in the ambulance service won't help I am sure the cuts in the NHS won't help either. The NHS is safe in Tory hands. I think not. I hope the lady is ok and gets better soon.
1:28pm Fri 28 Sep 12
ladysal says...
Fire Fly: whereabouts in the above quote does it mention nursing staff? From my own NHS experience, Receptionists are not good at doing anything outside "procedure" - even when the patient in question is arresting in front of their eyes.
Bearing in in mind that there was concern about a head injury, no member of NHS staff will move a patient without a doctor's say so - the article states clearly that the grand daughter was told that there were no doctors available. The way I read the article, it was Urgent Care which had no doctors available. What was the grand daughter to do: pick her up herself and lift her into a wheelchair?
As for her wet clothes: it is highly unlikely that the grand daughter was carrying a spare set of clothes for her grandmother to put on, so what do you suggest she put her in? At the very least she would have to make a choice between leaving in her in her current clothes and staying there to look after her, or leaving her on her own for around an hour while she travels home to get some spare clothes for her.
The whole situation is ridiculous and should never have happened. Common sense obviously isn't part of the training in this hospital.
1:40pm Fri 28 Sep 12
HairyBowls says...
3:03pm Fri 28 Sep 12
chris283 says...
3:54pm Fri 28 Sep 12
Fire Fly says...
With regards to there being no Doctors...it definitely wouldn't be the Urgent Care that didn't have any it would be Maple House where the Lady had her appointment, if the Urgent Care didn't have any Doctors the ambulance wouldn't have taken her there because it would have been shut. If im right memory clinics can run with Occupational therapists & Specialist Nurses.
Thing to remember here is the memory clinic isn't run by Burnley Hospital its run by the Lancashire Care Trust which is completely separate so they wouldn't have a clue what the staffing levels were for the hospital itself...only the unit where they were running the clinic that day.
If the lady could have got up, fair enough wheel her as the granddaughter said she'd do but she couldn't. If she had broken her hip & she was moved inappropriately, she may not have survived. So as dreadful as it was, she was best kept lying where she was.
Wet clothes, no I don't expect the granddaughter to run round at all but common sense could prevail on her side too & a gown be requested so the poor woman didn't have to sit there in wet clothes.
4:01pm Fri 28 Sep 12
Fire Fly says...
That aside, if you cast your mind back many months ago, I expressed a great deal of sympathy with the situation re your girlfriend because you raised in another post & I said then you should put in a negligence claim...I hope you did!
Also, i'm not a plank...by all means respond to my comments but there's no need to resort to petty name calling just because my views are different to yours.
4:12pm Fri 28 Sep 12
Rob Roy says...
4:27pm Fri 28 Sep 12
shytalk says...
4:34pm Fri 28 Sep 12
chris283 says...
7:20pm Fri 28 Sep 12
isitrightthat says...
No one without full medical knowledge moves anyone with a head injury or with a risk of a fracture to do so can create far more damage and pain specifically in older people .More so women because they often suffer more with osteoarthritis etc and low calcium.Hence more brittle bones .
To call for the sacking of nurses/ staff is only for those with ignorance of medical / nursing knowledge.
8:06pm Fri 28 Sep 12
DirtyHarry says...
8:59pm Fri 28 Sep 12
UKIP-Ron says...
fall in totaly with the EU safety regulations even if it means some one has to die.
I am fully trained in mouth to mouth but years ago a dictate came out dont try to safe some one using that methord you might get sued by the family if they die.
we in tthe UK are in a toat mess with all these faulty goverments we keep voting in.
we are regarded as phlebs by these self centred politicians who vote in all these life threating changes to save money so they can have a good life style. bet if it was an MP on the ground every one in the hospital would be at his /hers beck and call,,, sack all who refused to help this old lady with out fail and then sack every one who came up with the idea of moving every thing to blackburn.
9:11pm Fri 28 Sep 12
walsh33 says...
10:00pm Fri 28 Sep 12
Pendlesider says...
.
the urgent care centre (UCC) doctors round the corner were seemingly unaware of what had happened and should have been alerted.
.
An emergency ambulance was sent to a hospital that doesn't deal with emergencies. I was half expecting the poor woman to be shipped to the RoyHELL hospital in Blackburn.
.
Sadly, the above story about the pensioner left in the gutter is not unique.
.
In June 2010 a man had an epileptic fit in front of Burnley General Hospital yet he was sent 17 miles to Blackburn for treatment.
.
Another incident happened in Feb 09 where an elderly woman was taken by ambulance on a 17-mile trip to the Royal Blackburn Hospital after a car crash in the grounds of Burnley General Hospital.
.
So it seems if you have an accident at Burnley hospital you're either moved to another hospital 17 miles away or left in the gutter until an ambulance arrives.
This begs the question "is Burnley General Hospital really a hospital at all" ? debate...
mavericksunite.blogs
pot.co.uk
8:37am Sat 29 Sep 12
disgusted tunbridge wells says...
12:32pm Sat 29 Sep 12
isitrightthat says...
You obviously know nothing about moving people with head injuries or suspected fractures .Just like other ignorant people on here .
Nurses work off accountability and if they are not trained in providing certain types of treatment they should not administer any care or they are culpable and could lose their registration and be sacked or sued .
This incident happened outside the memory services unit which is staffed by psychiatric nurses and psychiatrist . None are trained in head injuries or suspected fractures .
So before you call for sackings get the facts right .
1:28pm Sat 29 Sep 12
commonsenseplease says...
I hope the lady is recovering well.
2:04pm Sat 29 Sep 12
ClitheroeKid says...
7:32pm Mon 1 Oct 12
nelmick says...