Blackburn RSS Feed Send your news, pictures & videos


LT block logo JOIN THE DEBATE BY ADDING YOUR COMMENTS ON THESE STORIES

Registering to post comments on the Lancashire Telegraph website only takes a few seconds. Click here to go to the registration page.

Blackburn with Darwen council refuses to reveal NHS chief pay-off


BLACKBURN with Darwen bosses have come under fire for refusing to reveal the pay-off given to a £130,000-a-year chief executive who departed as part of a ‘cost-saving’ drive.

Judith Griffin left her post in charge of the borough’s Primary Care Trust when it merged its management with Blackburn with Darwen Council in July.

It is claimed the move will save up to £2million, with dozens of managers to be made redundant as they compete for fewer jobs.

But now the two organisations have been criticised after refusing a request under the Freedom of Information Act for the amount of money given to Ms Griffin, who lost out to council chief executive Graham Burgess for the top job.

The trust claimed that to disclose the payment would breach the Data Protection Act, despite it having to publish the salaries of its high-earning staff in its annual accounts.

Coun Maureen Bateson, deputy leader of the council’s opposition Labour group, said: “I am not aware of the figure but I’m told it is considerable.

“I think the public needs to know what their money is being spent on.”

The council claimed that the standard NHS terms and conditions would produce a ‘misleading’ figure, but refused to confirm why this was.

However, a spokesman for the NHS Employers organisation, which represents health trusts on workforce issues, confirmed: “The NHS redundancy provisions allow for one month’s pay per year of continuous service, with a maximum of 24 months’ pay.

"This is the same whether someone is a nurse, doctor or senior manager.”

This would see Ms Griffin in line for a payment of more than £250,000, which would be on top of a pension awarded as a £150,000 lump sum followed by around £50,000 a year..

Tory council leader Michael Lee said: “There are strict legal restrictions which prevent details of redundancy arrangements from being disclosed.

"Any crude calculation made using the NHS national terms and conditions would result in a highly-inflated and misleading figure.

"The cost of this redundancy is met by the national NHS and has no effect on the savings for council taxpayers we will make from the management merger.”

Comments(13)

happycyclist says...
10:27am Sat 4 Sep 10

What is the point of the Freedom of Information Act if it discretionary?
It's plainly idiotic to claim that disclosure of the payoff would breach Data Protection rules if they have already disclosed her salary.

pez63 says...
11:10am Sat 4 Sep 10

Sickening amounts of money being handed over to a sellect few,and the rest of the country left to struggle through cut backs,it makes me feel sick just to read what as been disclosed so far,let alone what is really being kept from us. 21/12/12,Don`t ignore the facts.

time.team says...
12:09pm Sat 4 Sep 10

It’s just a case of the ‘New Labour’ Blackburm with Darwen labour council showing what it’s true colours are. Exactly what all ‘True Labour’ people thought Conservatives to be?
Jack Straw is still flying the ‘New Labour’ flag while still living in London and Graham Burgess who lives in Liverpool has now taken over those roles that have been axed. Very suspect moves?
-
‘New Labour Tony Blair‘ is now extremely well off when the country is not. Draw your own conclusions!

Eileen Dover says...
4:22pm Sat 4 Sep 10

time.team wrote:
It’s just a case of the ‘New Labour’ Blackburm with Darwen labour council showing what it’s true colours are. Exactly what all ‘True Labour’ people thought Conservatives to be? Jack Straw is still flying the ‘New Labour’ flag while still living in London and Graham Burgess who lives in Liverpool has now taken over those roles that have been axed. Very suspect moves? - ‘New Labour Tony Blair‘ is now extremely well off when the country is not. Draw your own conclusions!
What a nonsense comment - are you a simpleton? The labour party is not in power nationally or on the Council so if you are to blame someone blame the Torie/liberal alliance. I am a nurse in Preston and believe me the spin nationally that the government is making cuts to managers is nonsense. Already people leaving the NHS are being lined up by GPs and private sector firms to run health services. However, I would like to point out that to be fair to the condem government the figures quoted in this story are highly suspect and any payoff would be a fraction of this. The reporter was either on a short deadline or bored so simply added 2 plus 2 and made 5. Very shoddy.

whereistedward says...
5:09pm Sat 4 Sep 10

time.team wrote:
It’s just a case of the ‘New Labour’ Blackburm with Darwen labour council showing what it’s true colours are. Exactly what all ‘True Labour’ people thought Conservatives to be? Jack Straw is still flying the ‘New Labour’ flag while still living in London and Graham Burgess who lives in Liverpool has now taken over those roles that have been axed. Very suspect moves? - ‘New Labour Tony Blair‘ is now extremely well off when the country is not. Draw your own conclusions!
time.team is indeed in a time warp. BwD Council has been run by the Con/Lib-Dem/'For Darwen' coalition for just over 3 years now.
time.team needs to re-set the co-ordinates on his tardis to come into the 2010 time zone and not that of 2007 !

your granny says...
5:10pm Sat 4 Sep 10

Eileen Dover wrote:
time.team wrote: It’s just a case of the ‘New Labour’ Blackburm with Darwen labour council showing what it’s true colours are. Exactly what all ‘True Labour’ people thought Conservatives to be? Jack Straw is still flying the ‘New Labour’ flag while still living in London and Graham Burgess who lives in Liverpool has now taken over those roles that have been axed. Very suspect moves? - ‘New Labour Tony Blair‘ is now extremely well off when the country is not. Draw your own conclusions!
What a nonsense comment - are you a simpleton? The labour party is not in power nationally or on the Council so if you are to blame someone blame the Torie/liberal alliance. I am a nurse in Preston and believe me the spin nationally that the government is making cuts to managers is nonsense. Already people leaving the NHS are being lined up by GPs and private sector firms to run health services. However, I would like to point out that to be fair to the condem government the figures quoted in this story are highly suspect and any payoff would be a fraction of this. The reporter was either on a short deadline or bored so simply added 2 plus 2 and made 5. Very shoddy.
when it comes to shoddy, this paper is becoming a world leader. For what it's worth, I hope you are still in a job after the dust has settled. These new fangled charity status private sector companies are all the fashion and just privatisation by the back door.

Davidoff says...
5:35pm Sat 4 Sep 10

It's really quite simple ... yes, it's digusting, sickening even to read ... yet it's so 'atypically' British, reward failure with bonuses, let the rest who haven't failed rot, starve and struggle ...

.

But it's simple because this is the plan: make it so no one living in certain areas - which just happen to be North of Watford, they are even boasting about how the cuts won't affect the south and, guess what?, London particularly and the south east, now what does that tell anyone - can afford to access any free healthcare and ... force the county into a no win situation ie private healthcare. But only for those who can afford it.

.

And to Eileen I would simply say this: 'enjoy your job whilst you can'.

Eileen Dover says...
9:05pm Sat 4 Sep 10

your granny wrote:
Eileen Dover wrote:
time.team wrote: It’s just a case of the ‘New Labour’ Blackburm with Darwen labour council showing what it’s true colours are. Exactly what all ‘True Labour’ people thought Conservatives to be? Jack Straw is still flying the ‘New Labour’ flag while still living in London and Graham Burgess who lives in Liverpool has now taken over those roles that have been axed. Very suspect moves? - ‘New Labour Tony Blair‘ is now extremely well off when the country is not. Draw your own conclusions!
What a nonsense comment - are you a simpleton? The labour party is not in power nationally or on the Council so if you are to blame someone blame the Torie/liberal alliance. I am a nurse in Preston and believe me the spin nationally that the government is making cuts to managers is nonsense. Already people leaving the NHS are being lined up by GPs and private sector firms to run health services. However, I would like to point out that to be fair to the condem government the figures quoted in this story are highly suspect and any payoff would be a fraction of this. The reporter was either on a short deadline or bored so simply added 2 plus 2 and made 5. Very shoddy.
when it comes to shoddy, this paper is becoming a world leader. For what it's worth, I hope you are still in a job after the dust has settled. These new fangled charity status private sector companies are all the fashion and just privatisation by the back door.
Thanks, sadly morale in the nursing profession is very low not just in our ward but in many hospitals. I lost three colleagues in the last 6 months to jobs in the private sector. It is not their fault, they have mortgages and families and we are being offered better terms and working conditions in the private sector. The RCN seems oblivious to the problems and more concerned with not upsetting a dept of health in turmoil. I'm lucky, I'm fairly near retirement but young nurses are opting for other professions.

Eileen Dover says...
9:49pm Sat 4 Sep 10

Davidoff wrote:
It's really quite simple ... yes, it's digusting, sickening even to read ... yet it's so 'atypically' British, reward failure with bonuses, let the rest who haven't failed rot, starve and struggle ...

.

But it's simple because this is the plan: make it so no one living in certain areas - which just happen to be North of Watford, they are even boasting about how the cuts won't affect the south and, guess what?, London particularly and the south east, now what does that tell anyone - can afford to access any free healthcare and ... force the county into a no win situation ie private healthcare. But only for those who can afford it.

.

And to Eileen I would simply say this: 'enjoy your job whilst you can'.
Good point. People should wake up and
Smell the coffee - we are very close to having companies like Virgin running our NHS - are we all happy with that?? The NHS is a public service not a business and until we accept that fact it will be run like a business with the patients losing out. The government believes GPs are the answer but believe me GPs will be the first to award themselves hefty pay rises when they hey their hands on all that lovely lolly - they did in the past when GP fundholding was introduced and will do so again. People need to see past the smiley face of Mr Cameron and look at the real agenda of the government - the dismantling of the NHS. They don't believe in it's ethos and as soon as they get the sniff of a chance will try and break it up as they have started with their plans for GP
Commissioning. Meanwhile the media turns a blind eye or as this article has shown prefer instead to indulge in a bit of NHS bashing.

mavrick says...
10:33pm Sat 4 Sep 10

The tories along with the agree to anything to have a title lib dems, The total destruction of the N.H.S is now in sight for the gloating tories. I hope the doctors involved in this sell out will hang their heads in shame, of course the money they will be able to demand will ease their conscience.
This may sound far fetched but it is nearer than you dare think.
Jobs for the boys has just taken on a new meaning.

hasslem hasslem says...
10:59pm Sat 4 Sep 10

whereistedward wrote:
time.team wrote:
It’s just a case of the ‘New Labour’ Blackburm with Darwen labour council showing what it’s true colours are. Exactly what all ‘True Labour’ people thought Conservatives to be? Jack Straw is still flying the ‘New Labour’ flag while still living in London and Graham Burgess who lives in Liverpool has now taken over those roles that have been axed. Very suspect moves? - ‘New Labour Tony Blair‘ is now extremely well off when the country is not. Draw your own conclusions!
time.team is indeed in a time warp. BwD Council has been run by the Con/Lib-Dem/'For Darwen' coalition for just over 3 years now.
time.team needs to re-set the co-ordinates on his tardis to come into the 2010 time zone and not that of 2007 !
i dont know about whereistedward - more like where is whereistedward? - thought you were meant to be in chicago.....incident
ally the most corrupt city administration in US.
.
Coincidence?

time.team says...
10:37am Sun 5 Sep 10

Dangle a worm and your bound to attract sharks!
Un-great small new red ones.

daan says...
7:26pm Mon 6 Sep 10

why not put David Dunn and Graham Alexander outside the front door that will make everybody feel better ! oh sorry that isnt really relevant to this story, then again its got nothing to do with the fact that due to spending cuts expectant mothers from Blackburn will have to travel all the way to Burnley to give birth. hope she enjoys my tax money Im sure she thoughrily deserves it.


MOVE: Judith Griffin MOVE: Judith Griffin

Most popular


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »

Local Businesses