On a day when the cathedral hosts a Passover Supper led by a Rabbi from the Jewish community in Blackpool, Canon Chris Chivers argues that the confessional nature of Lent needs to take Christians where they perhaps don't want to go.
Lent and now Holy Week are all about owning our sinfulness as human beings and owning up to our sins.
When I worked as a priest at Westminster Abbey I took hundreds - probably thousands - of people around that amazing building.
I often met them at the Great West Door, and they all knew, of course, that inside the door was the tomb of the Unknown Warrior.
advertisement
They wanted to get there and to snap away with their cameras or set the video whirring.
But I always tried - not always with success! - to stop them in their tracks and to invite them to read the prayer inscribed on the stone to the left of the door:
God grant to the living grace, to the departed rest, to the Church, the Commonwealth and the whole World peace and concord, and to us sinners life everlasting.
It was the last phrase I most wanted them to focus on.
"There's a connection," I'd say, "between that phrase and the tomb you're about to see.
"It's made through that little word: sin."
It's a connection societies have too often lost over the past one hundred or so years because we've been busy pretending that sin isn't as bad as it really is.
Adultery: "Oh that's just a 'bit on the side'."
Fraud: "You know she always sailed close to the wind."
Prostitution and pornography: "Well, boys will be boys."
Domestic violence: "It's the culture you know, 'the way things are.'"
Theft: "He didn't take that much: they can afford to be without it anyway."
It's fair enough that we can't live with our sinfulness: because of course it causes us deep feelings of revulsion and remorse, whatever we say on the surface.
And it's fair enough too to say that the Church has majored much too heavily in the past on sin - especially on sexual sin.
But we can't just dismiss sin, as if it's of no consequence.
We actually need more sinners: more people prepared to own and own up to their sinfulness.
Read the story that dominates this week, for instance, the story of Jesus's passion, suffering, death and resurrection, and you'll perhaps be shocked to notice that sin is deeply embedded within the way the Christian tradition tells its story.
You'll have to get past a lot of stereotypes - the standard view of Pharisees and Jews, for instance, as Satan incarnate.
But see those card-board cut-out characterisations of people for what they are - yes, the tabloid stuff is there even in the Bible - and you'll perhaps have discovered one of its greatest fault-lines.
For this reveals itself almost every time Pharisees and Jews are in fact mentioned, because with each mention nails are driven not into the crucified Christ but into a community which has for far too much of Christian history been mistakenly, cruelly, and with devastating effect held responsible for Jesus's death.
Some Jews, even Pharisees perhaps, and some Romans of course were part of the complex set of decisions that saw the Nazarene crucified on the first Good Friday.
The scholars now pretty-much agree that he died because he threatened the collusive relationship between Jewish temple authorities and the Roman occupying power: the kind of symbiotic relationship of the mutually evil that we see in Harare, for example, between some Anglicans and President Robert Mugabe.
But it's wrong - and plain sinful - to take that polemical story-telling and to say, as the Church has so often threateningly said, that all Jews are responsible eternally for his death.
Wrong, because it's a historical nonsense and an insult to living Judaism.
And wrong because there's a link between saying this and the terrible persecution that Jews have suffered across their history at the hands of so-called Christians, whether that's Jews walled up in York in the thirteenth century, Jews sent to Auschwitz in the twentieth, or the exhibition Anne Frank + You desecrated in Liverpool Cathedral in the twenty-first by people wanting to perpetuate misinterpretations, lies and exaggerations - yes, there are some of those in the Gospels too.
People like me must realise that the crucified Lord, whilst a symbol of suffering love to Christians, is a potent and terrifying sign of ill-treatment and possible death for Jews.
As an institution, living in the shadow of the Shoah, the annihilation - as Jews prefer to call the Holocaust - much of the Church has come to see that the way in which the New Testament is written - indeed the way Christians talk about new versus old, as if old is outworn and superseded - comes from a time when the 'new' Christian reality was trying to establish itself over-against the 'old' Jewish tradition.
As in any move from adolescence to maturity, the push for independence leads the child - Christianity - to say things to and about the parent - Judaism - which are the kind of horrid, exaggerated things you say in the heat of teenage tantrums with their overly-bold assertion that 'I'm right' and with their equally clear implication that 'You're wrong.'
But understandable though this rhetoric of hatred is, it has not been simply a passing adolescent phase, it's devastated Jewish lives down the centuries - some 6 million of them down the centuries.
Which is why, as the Rabbi at the Passover supper in the cathedral tonight begins to tell the old, old story of a people brought to freedom in the promised land from slavery in Egypt, and crossing the red sea to get there, I'll be praying that my Christian tradition can move further to free itself from the negative consequences of the manner in which it's interpreted God's saving love in Jesus Christ.
I'll ask that we can be as self-critical of our religious tradition as was Jesus of his - remembering that as a symbol of this the veil of the temple was torn in two from top to bottom on Good Friday.
That's what needs to happen. For the divine grace and love that emanates from Calvary - and later from an empty tomb - wasn't given at the expense or to the detriment of my Jewish neighbours.
It was given so that all might be free.
I'll also pray for courage to recognise this sin and to remove any lingering traces of it because, frankly, though we've made much headway since 1945, we're far from free of anti-Judaism or its wicked twin, anti-Semitism.
Indeed, despite the way in which the Roman Catholic Church has so often led the way in these matters, the present Pope has himself has fallen fowl of this Christian fault-line in his stubborn refusal to remove all anti-Judaism from the Latin prayers for Good Friday when he recently had them revised.
We have a long way to go. But we can now, thankfully, travel the road as fellow 'sinners' - Christian, Jew, Muslim, Hindu, Jain, Buddhist, Sikh, Baha'i, Zoroastrian, Humanist, Agnostic and Atheist even - as those prepared to take responsibility for our mistakes, to own and own up to them, and to ensure that never again will we project them onto another target group.
Which is why today at the cathedral we also welcome Moazzam Begg, the former Guantanamo Bay detainee, since the latest such target seems to be Muslims, and we know only too well from the Jewish experience where that targeting could chillingly lead us, and more importantly, them.
Moazzam Begg is in conversation with Canon Chris Chivers, Anjum Anwar MBE and Canon Michael Hunn in Blackburn Cathedral today from 1.05-1.55pm.
Posted by: Ann, Blackburn on 11:13am Tue 18 Mar 08
Thank you Canon Chivers for a very eloquent, profound and deeply touching 'blog'. (Rather I would say Sermon). Perhaps if we took it to heart we would more readily accept our own sins and not be too ready to judge the sins of others. Thank you.
Thank you Canon Chivers for a very eloquent, profound and deeply touching 'blog'. (Rather I would say Sermon). Perhaps if we took it to heart we would more readily accept our own sins and not be too ready to judge the sins of others. Thank you.
Posted by: simplysimon, burnley on 11:54am Tue 18 Mar 08
Hi Chris,
God has never counted sins. If God were to count our sins he would have no room left over to move. It is not the mistakes that count.
It is the mistakes that DONT GET COUNTED.
God want's us to be Impressed. God gives us the GIFT OF EXISTENCE in the Hope that we will be Impressed with it. Nobody offers a Gift in the Hope that we will not be IMPRESSED!
God is looking for the appreciation within our HEARTS. no amount of confessions and phoney cover-up jobs is going to cut it with God. God is not Impressed with the number of trips we made to the confessional box. No!
When there is [bold]Appreciation[/bold] for the Gift of Existence. [italic]Heart-felt[/italic] Appreciation. All our Human stains are cleaned away. That is the soap that cleans away mortal stains. [bold]Appreciation.[/bold]
God has better things to do than count our stains. In this world there will always be stains. Like smoke beclouds the fire. No Man is Perfect. Most can be Stupid.
It is not about our successes or our failures. We are Appreciating Creatures. We have been fashioned with a Heart that can APPRECIATE.
Hi Chris,
God has never counted sins. If God were to count our sins he would have no room left over to move. It is not the mistakes that count.
It is the mistakes that DONT GET COUNTED.
God want's us to be Impressed. God gives us the GIFT OF EXISTENCE in the Hope that we will be Impressed with it. Nobody offers a Gift in the Hope that we will not be IMPRESSED!
God is looking for the appreciation within our HEARTS. no amount of confessions and phoney cover-up jobs is going to cut it with God. God is not Impressed with the number of trips we made to the confessional box. No!
When there is Appreciation for the Gift of Existence. Heart-felt Appreciation. All our Human stains are cleaned away. That is the soap that cleans away mortal stains. Appreciation.
God has better things to do than count our stains. In this world there will always be stains. Like smoke beclouds the fire. No Man is Perfect. Most can be Stupid.
It is not about our successes or our failures. We are Appreciating Creatures. We have been fashioned with a Heart that can APPRECIATE.
Posted by: simplysimon, burnley on 12:50pm Tue 18 Mar 08
Dear ANN,
Don't spend too much time accepting your sins. Nobody is expected to be Perfect. Job done.
Accepting Your Gift of Existence in the way it should be Accepted. With Every Breath that comes into you.
If You want to get good at something then get good at Accepting this Beautiful Gift of Your Existence that is constantly showering down upon you. This gift of Life-Giving Breaths never ceases to accompany you. You have won the war, you have been awarded the Ultimate most Magnificent Gift! You are ALIVE! You EXIST! It's a Miracle! it should be enough to blow your mind! It should be enough to fill you with Gratitude from the top of your head to the tips of your toes!
Just a little Gratitude is enough to move the Heart of God. God likes his Heart to be touched.
Dear ANN,
Don't spend too much time accepting your sins. Nobody is expected to be Perfect. Job done.
Accepting Your Gift of Existence in the way it should be Accepted. With Every Breath that comes into you.
If You want to get good at something then get good at Accepting this Beautiful Gift of Your Existence that is constantly showering down upon you. This gift of Life-Giving Breaths never ceases to accompany you. You have won the war, you have been awarded the Ultimate most Magnificent Gift! You are ALIVE! You EXIST! It's a Miracle! it should be enough to blow your mind! It should be enough to fill you with Gratitude from the top of your head to the tips of your toes!
Just a little Gratitude is enough to move the Heart of God. God likes his Heart to be touched.
Simon. I do appreciate the gift of my existence,I appreciate every day that God allows me. I exist, I am unique and when I sin I take that to God with repentence and leave it with Him. I could go to Confession everyday but without the repentence it would be a meaningless act. I do not beat myself every day about my failings, I accept my imperfect humanity as does God and I get on with life knowing that I am loved.
Simon. I do appreciate the gift of my existence,I appreciate every day that God allows me. I exist, I am unique and when I sin I take that to God with repentence and leave it with Him. I could go to Confession everyday but without the repentence it would be a meaningless act. I do not beat myself every day about my failings, I accept my imperfect humanity as does God and I get on with life knowing that I am loved.
Posted by: simplysimon, burnley on 3:12pm Tue 18 Mar 08
Dear Ann,
You get on with your Life Knowing that you are Loved. With every Breath you are Cherished with the Tenderness of Divinity. You are never going to be judged by that Tenderness. A Woman is a True Advocate for the Heart.
Dear Ann,
You get on with your Life Knowing that you are Loved. With every Breath you are Cherished with the Tenderness of Divinity. You are never going to be judged by that Tenderness. A Woman is a True Advocate for the Heart.
Posted by: Joseph Yossarian, London on 10:09am Wed 19 Mar 08
It is good to see a member of the church admitting that the actions of the church in the past have been deplorable.
Makes me wonder what members of the church will be saying in years ahead; what actions of today's 2007 church will be considered reprehensible?
It is good to see a member of the church admitting that the actions of the church in the past have been deplorable.
Makes me wonder what members of the church will be saying in years ahead; what actions of today's 2007 church will be considered reprehensible?
Posted by: Joseph Yossarian, London on 2:18pm Wed 19 Mar 08
[quote][bold]Joseph Yossarian[/bold] wrote:
It is good to see a member of the church admitting that the actions of the church in the past have been deplorable. Makes me wonder what members of the church will be saying in years ahead; what actions of today's 2007 church will be considered reprehensible? [/quote] For example, keeping a convicted child sex offender on full pay. . . . .
Joseph Yossarian wrote:
It is good to see a member of the church admitting that the actions of the church in the past have been deplorable. Makes me wonder what members of the church will be saying in years ahead; what actions of today's 2007 church will be considered reprehensible?
For example, keeping a convicted child sex offender on full pay. . . . .
Posted by: simplysimon, burnley on 12:41pm Thu 20 Mar 08
In the past, the actions of Man have been deplorable. Royal Mistakes have been made.
If Men can learn to live for this Moment!
This Church will refuse to be chained to the past.
In the past, the actions of Man have been deplorable. Royal Mistakes have been made.
If Men can learn to live for this Moment!
This Church will refuse to be chained to the past.
If you liked this article and would like to share it with others on the web who might be searching for good content we've made it easy for you to do it.
At the bottom of all articles, you'll see links to six sites. These sites - commonly called 'social bookmark' or 'social news' sites - have large communities of web users who share and rate interesting, useful and fun things on the web.
Clicking the links will automatically add the address of the story you are reading to one of these sites, letting you share it with others. Each site will ask you to register to share stories. Registration is free and once a member, you can store, recommend and search for stories that interest you.
Print
Email this
Comment
