Lancashire TelegraphTeachers’ backing for East Lancs head’s inspired letter (From Lancashire Telegraph)

When news happens, text LT and your photos and videos to 80360. Or contact us by email or phone.

Teachers’ backing for East Lancs head’s inspired letter

Lancashire Telegraph: Charlie Owen with mum Alison, who first tweeted the letter and dad Chez. Charlie Owen with mum Alison, who first tweeted the letter and dad Chez.

WHEN head teacher Rachel Tomlinson wrote an end of term letter to her Year 6 Barrowford primary school pupils there was no way she could have known that it contents would soon be published around the world.

While the school’s SATS results were very good, she went on to tell the youngsters that exams do not always assess what makes them ‘special and unique’.

Her actions, which went viral on social media, have been widely praised for pointing out how important educating the whole person is, not just training people to pass tests.

Paul Oliver, spokesman for Blackburn’s Queen Elizabeth’s Grammar School, described the letter to 10 and 11-year-olds as ‘refreshing’.

He said: “It’s really time that someone put it into perspective. Schools are about more than just exams. It’s right that they focus on social and emotional development too. Every school has a wider brief than just tests and this school is just showing that they realise that.”

Headteacher at Haslingden High Mark Jackson said: “I completely agree with the sentiments of the letter. It’s not that tests don’t count, it’s just they are not the be all and end all. It’s really refreshing in these times of Ofsted pressures to see a school and headteacher who think there is more to being a fantastic school then just results.”

Schools councillor for Blackburn with Darwen Dave Harling said the letter to Key Stage 2 test pupils was an example to other schools.

He said: “I think it’s a lovely letter. It says all the things each pupil has got to offer which cannot be defined by tests.

“However we have a system which currently places all the emphasis on tests. It’s great of the headteacher to remind the pupils of all the things they don’t measure. Of course English and numeracy tests are important but they don’t tell a university or an employer about all the things this person can do.”

Hyndburn’s conservative leader and former teacher Peter Britcliffe said he thought the country had ‘gone testing mad’.

He said: “While tests are important, I don’t like such a focus on them, particularly at the primary school age.

“When I was at school in the fifties you had a test every Friday and you would be numbered from 1 to 36 on the result. Not so good if you were not near the top.

“I see the value in testing to check on ability levels and where children need help but there shouldn’t be so much pressure at so early an age.

“There seems to be a cycle where education goes through phases. Whenever it has been in fashion, I have never been a fan of tests, tests, tests.”

Assistant head teacher at Sacred Heart Primary in Blackburn, Liz Beaumont said: “In the climate of constant academic testing, most schools are striving to maintain a nurturing climate. One which values all children's unique talents, skills and personal qualities.

“I hope now this letter has gone viral and evoked so much admiration, the public will want to see more than test results, Ofsted categories and league tables. Where they judge the effectiveness of schools in raising successful, balanced and confident learners."

Darwen Vale teacher and NASUWT union representative Claire Ward added: “Part of the reaction to this letter is because people are fed up of over testing. It’s fair to say the exam culture and treating children like pieces of data has gotten old for many teachers and parents.”

Comments (6)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

5:51pm Thu 17 Jul 14

Minnie the moocher says...

This head teacher has received so much praise for what? Cutting and pasting a real letter off the internet and sending it out as her own? Has she actually admitted that she stole the idea and the letter yet?
Surely not a good example for the children?
This head teacher has received so much praise for what? Cutting and pasting a real letter off the internet and sending it out as her own? Has she actually admitted that she stole the idea and the letter yet? Surely not a good example for the children? Minnie the moocher
  • Score: -2

6:41pm Thu 17 Jul 14

Dave from Colne says...

Minnie the moocher wrote:
This head teacher has received so much praise for what? Cutting and pasting a real letter off the internet and sending it out as her own? Has she actually admitted that she stole the idea and the letter yet?
Surely not a good example for the children?
Someone else may have written part or all of it and this is well known but being negative this way detracts from the fact that children need as much praise, confidence and morale boosting at stressful times like taking exams. Why can't she remind her pupils that they are all special in their own way? Stop being so negative. Don't forget she didn't ask for it to be posted all over the internet. Sounds like a bit of jealousy here.
[quote][p][bold]Minnie the moocher[/bold] wrote: This head teacher has received so much praise for what? Cutting and pasting a real letter off the internet and sending it out as her own? Has she actually admitted that she stole the idea and the letter yet? Surely not a good example for the children?[/p][/quote]Someone else may have written part or all of it and this is well known but being negative this way detracts from the fact that children need as much praise, confidence and morale boosting at stressful times like taking exams. Why can't she remind her pupils that they are all special in their own way? Stop being so negative. Don't forget she didn't ask for it to be posted all over the internet. Sounds like a bit of jealousy here. Dave from Colne
  • Score: 9

6:43pm Thu 17 Jul 14

grumpyoldlady says...

Yes she did state that she copied the letter when she appeared on Radio 4's Woman's Hour early this week. It would do no harm for other head teachers to show that all the children are valued for their various talents. Not every child is academic, but many will go on to have good careers in the fields of art and sport and many other areas.
Yes she did state that she copied the letter when she appeared on Radio 4's Woman's Hour early this week. It would do no harm for other head teachers to show that all the children are valued for their various talents. Not every child is academic, but many will go on to have good careers in the fields of art and sport and many other areas. grumpyoldlady
  • Score: 7

7:02pm Thu 17 Jul 14

Minnie the moocher says...

Dave from Colne wrote:
Minnie the moocher wrote:
This head teacher has received so much praise for what? Cutting and pasting a real letter off the internet and sending it out as her own? Has she actually admitted that she stole the idea and the letter yet?
Surely not a good example for the children?
Someone else may have written part or all of it and this is well known but being negative this way detracts from the fact that children need as much praise, confidence and morale boosting at stressful times like taking exams. Why can't she remind her pupils that they are all special in their own way? Stop being so negative. Don't forget she didn't ask for it to be posted all over the internet. Sounds like a bit of jealousy here.
Why would I be jealous of the pretend praise primary school children have been given by this fraudster? My daughter attended her school and I can well remember sitting there, completely astonished, at a school show. Ms Tomlinson had decided to call it a "cabaret", and watching her neck copious amounts of wine ...and encouraging parents to nip to the offy across the road to do the same!! I know it was an after-school event, but, come on!
Was that another "good idea" pinched from elsewhere?
I agree wholeheartedly that children respond positively to praise, and it think the sentiment was lovely.... but surely, at least do a bit of a rewrite to put your own personality into the words, otherwise it could feel a bit....cheap?
[quote][p][bold]Dave from Colne[/bold] wrote: [quote][p][bold]Minnie the moocher[/bold] wrote: This head teacher has received so much praise for what? Cutting and pasting a real letter off the internet and sending it out as her own? Has she actually admitted that she stole the idea and the letter yet? Surely not a good example for the children?[/p][/quote]Someone else may have written part or all of it and this is well known but being negative this way detracts from the fact that children need as much praise, confidence and morale boosting at stressful times like taking exams. Why can't she remind her pupils that they are all special in their own way? Stop being so negative. Don't forget she didn't ask for it to be posted all over the internet. Sounds like a bit of jealousy here.[/p][/quote]Why would I be jealous of the pretend praise primary school children have been given by this fraudster? My daughter attended her school and I can well remember sitting there, completely astonished, at a school show. Ms Tomlinson had decided to call it a "cabaret", and watching her neck copious amounts of wine ...and encouraging parents to nip to the offy across the road to do the same!! I know it was an after-school event, but, come on! Was that another "good idea" pinched from elsewhere? I agree wholeheartedly that children respond positively to praise, and it think the sentiment was lovely.... but surely, at least do a bit of a rewrite to put your own personality into the words, otherwise it could feel a bit....cheap? Minnie the moocher
  • Score: -4

5:49am Fri 18 Jul 14

Graham Hartley says...

teacher = cheater (anagram)
teacher = cheater (anagram) Graham Hartley
  • Score: -3

8:14am Fri 18 Jul 14

Mattytatty says...

It made the news here in New Zealand
It made the news here in New Zealand Mattytatty
  • Score: 1

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree